Julie Etchingham did well: fair, composed, in charge, and pleasantly old-fashioned when she addressed the two contestants as “gentlemen”, though she did on one occasion make the mistake of addressing the Labour leader as “Mr Keir Starmer”.
But if this were a panel game, one would have to say it was so dull it should never be played again. The format forced both contestants to maintain a tense and stilted professionalism, competing to see which of them could repeat his key messages the most often.
There was no rule in this contest against repetition. Again and again, Rishi Sunak warned us that “Labour will raise your taxes”. Again and again, Starmer said “we’ve got to stop the chaos”.
We heard, repeatedly, that Starmer’s Dad was a toolmaker and his wife works for the NHS. We heard, repeatedly, that Sunak was brought up in an NHS household, by a doctor and a pharmacist.
These credentials were meant to show that they themselves are normal people, who can feel the pain of the millions of normal people who may or may not vote for them.
But did either man feel the pain of the viewers? Had they given any thought to how they might ease our suffering? Did they not realise how excruciating it is to watch two grown men competing in this formulaic way to do each other down?
Starmer allowed himself from time to time a small, derisive smile, to indicate how absurd he found Sunak’s contentions.
Sunak posed extra questions, to try to put his opponent on the spot, and gave dark looks to indicate his contempt for Starmer’s answers.
Some of those answers were indeed a bit thin. When challenged to explain how he would end the doctors’ strike, Starmer replied: “The grown-up way to do that is to get in the room and negotiate a settlement.”
Hmmm. We’ll see how well that goes.
Etchingham asked each contestant if he would buy private health for a member of his family who was not getting essential treatment from the NHS. Sunak replied “Yes”. Starmer replied “No”, added “I don’t use private health”, and reminded us that “my wife works in the NHS”.
Those who attempted after the contest to work out who had won generally omitted the possibility that both contestants had lost, in the sense of making people less likely to vote for them.
“Are you two gentlemen being honest?” Etchingham asked at one point.
“Please, gentlemen, we will lower our voices,” she added a few minutes later.
Part of the trouble was that neither of them was prepared to treat the other as a gentleman, i.e. as someone who could be relied upon to be honourable.
Each wished to show the other up as a scoundrel: a mean-minded endeavour.
In the Commons, members are obliged to refer to each other as “honourable”, a necessary condition for having a debate which does not degenerate into playground cries of “liar”.
“It’s hard to respond because he makes it up,” Starmer said towards the end.
“He is going to put up your taxes,” Sunak retorted.
They behaved more like boot boys than gentlemen. However hard Etchingham tried to uphold the Queensberry Rules, the fighters tried harder to strike low blows.
They had been coached by their seconds to strike low blows, but in that ignoble art, neither man outclassed the other. As at Prime Minister’s Questions, Sunak, though in opinion-poll terms the underdog, saw off all attempts to humiliate him.
But with what relief we reached the end of the contest and could turn it off.