Last night at a glittering awards ceremony held in a community centre next to an all-weather pitch in North London where Sir Keir Starmer once shouted “Give it to Keir” while playing in a football match, this column announced the following five prizes for political books published in the last year, chosen from a short list of all those reviewed on ConHome:
MOST PRESCIENT BOOK:
A Century of Labour by Jon Cruddas
At the start of this history of the competing traditions within the Labour Party, published in January 2024 on the hundredth anniversary of Ramsay MacDonald becoming the first Labour Prime Minister (see illustration above of him gazing dubiously at his latest successor), Cruddas writes:
“Starmer often seems detached from his own party and uncomfortable in communion with fellow MPs. In his immediate circle he appears to value the familiar and unchallenging. It is difficult to identify the purpose of a future Starmer government.”
At the end of the book Cruddas warns:
“Labour often recoils into a default instrumentalism, reliant on capitalist growth to prosper. Such growth looks an unlikely immediate prospect. Stale technocratic social democracy will prove unable to resist the rise of authoritarian populism.”
MOST DELIGHTFUL BOOK:
Queen Victoria and her Prime Ministers: A Personal History by Anne Somerset
Queen Victoria possessed, Somerset observes about half-way through this wonderful book, “an instinctive flair for theatrical gestures”.
There is an operatic quality about Victoria’s dealings with her ten Prime Ministers. We find ourselves watching a grand but comic opera crammed with unexpected changes of fortune and sung with marvellous passion and sincerity as a series of duets.
Somerset presents us with a woman of amazing vitality who all her life resisted the constraints of her role as a constitutional monarch, while taking with the utmost seriousness her duty to uphold the Constitution.
BEST MURDER STORY:
Kingmaker: Secrets, Lies and the Truth about Five Prime Ministers by Graham Brady
As Chairman of the 1922 Committee from 2010-24, Brady had a hand in finishing off PM after PM. He is a clunky writer, less smooth than David Cameron, but for that reason more authentic. He conveys and explains the deep unhappiness of many Tory MPs as Cameron led the party away from Tory verities, did a deal with the Lib Dems and became a murder target.
Historians who wish to understand why Cameron and so many other Tory PMs were killed off in such a short time will find this book invaluable.
BEST ACCOUNT OF BORIS JOHNSON:
OUT: How Brexit Got Done and the Tories Were Undone by Tim Shipman
In 20 or 30 years’ time, one trusts that some writer will do for Johnson what Charles Moore has done for Margaret Thatcher: provide an authoritative and incisive account after talking to everyone and reading the official papers. One envies whichever biographer gets hold of Johnson’s annotations on those papers.
But Shipman’s account is meanwhile much the fullest we have got, and he also recounts with fairness and vivacity the prime ministerships of Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak.
BEST ACCOUNT BY BORIS JOHNSON:
Johnson relates in this memoir that after withdrawing the Whip from the 21 Tory MPs including Oliver Letwin, Ken Clarke and Nicholas Soames in September 2019, “I felt like Octavian – that chill and subtle tyrant – ordering the proscription of names from the grandest senatorial families.”
Octavian became better known as the Emperor Augustus. He preserved the forms of the Roman Republic while changing it into the Roman Empire.
This book confirms Johnson’s monarchical outlook. He is not by temperament a parliamentarian, and after winning a general election against Parliament, proceeded to botch his relations with Tory MPs.
But what a merry monarch we find in these pages. Often we laughed out loud. Johnson may not be as amusing as Disraeli, a figure of whom he appears to know little, but he is the funniest and most literate PM since Macmillan.