Does Kemi Badenoch actually want to lead the Conservative Party?
This seems a bizarre question to ask. After all, it’s not that easy to climb the greasy pole. Even with her lackadaisical approach to campaigning for the job, Badenoch still needed to win over enough MPs and party members to to the top. Then again, she was run far closer than two years as the frontrunner might have led one to expect her to be. The Movement is losing its touch.
But she still won, even if it wasn’t the smooth coronation she might have hoped for. So after having gone to all that trouble, one would assume there is a part of her that wants to be our leader. But unless she is playing a grand practical joke upon her colleagues, one struggles to explain performances like that at last week’s PMQs without pinning it on a fundamental lack of interest.
She achieved what had been thought impossible: she made Keir Starmer look good. She had pinned her hopes on the Prime Minister saying what she wanted about Gazan refugees and appeared dumbfounded and defensive when he did not. He ran rings around her as she accused him of failing to answer a question that he had. She was on autopilot, unable to adapt or improvise.
Compounding by a final question about a civil servant working from home that Starmer summarily dismissed, the various reports about her PMQs prep seemed to ring true. It has been said that she doesn’t properly prepare, confident as she is in her abilities, that she has failed to consult those who had helped previous party leaders, and that she is “surrounded by sycophants”.
Now, some close to her have made clear to me that she has improved her prep in recent weeks. But when I read that she was uninterested in William Hague’s advice as to how to perform at the dispatch box, I despaired. Yes, he was far from our most electorally successful leader. But he did, by common consensus, run rings around Tony Blair at PMQs for four years.
Whether she likes it or not, it is Badenoch’s One Big Job a week. Even if few voters prioritise it at the ballot box, her six questions are her one guaranteed moment in the spotlight: a chance to contrast herself to Starmer, humiliate his government, push our attack lines, and cheer her weary colleagues. Her predecessors in the role have understood this and taken it sufficiently seriously.
But however heroically CCHQ tries to cover for her underwhelming performances by pumping out “Kemi OWNS Starmer” YouTube clips, the cracks are starting to show. She was elected because she was supposed to take the fight to Starmer, and he can’t believe his luck. Labour types were relieved when she won. They seem to have seen her faults far more clearly than we did.
This is why, so soon after reaching only a hundred days in the role, speculation is rife as to whether Badenoch will reach her double century. As Tom McTague suggests, one doesn’t have to go as far as Dominic Cummings in branding her a “complete useless dud” who needs to be removed “ASAP” to agree there is “substance to [his] condemnation of Badenoch’s leadership so far”.
Reading the ever-excellent Tali Fraser’s profile of Badenoch’s tenure so far gives a fascinating insight into the parallel universe inhabited by our leader and her team. In this world, Reform UK is a temporary phenomenon, not a party that has pushed us into third and is taking our voters, members, and donors with alacrity. She has three years to prove herself, not three months.
But reality cannot be fooled. By Nigel Huddleston’s own apparent assessment, we are already on track to lose half our councillors and all but one of the councils we are contesting. However hard CCHQ tries to massage expectations, the headlines on May 2nd will read “Reform surge. Tories wiped out”, accompanied by a cheering Nigel Farage and a glowering Badenoch.
Can this be avoided? Since these elections (or those which Angela Rayner has allowed to go ahead) were last contested at the peak of the 2021 vaccine bounce, they would have been difficult for any leader. But it is undoubtedly the case that Badenoch’s current strategy is making the situation worse. Voters already hated us. Now they are ignoring us. We are an irrelevance.
If her only strategy for reaching the electorate is to tour associations and appear on boomer podcasts, we will lose. If she continues to plan not to announce any policies until 2027 whilst Reform flood the airwaves, we will lose. If she continues to persist in dreaming that she has three years to turn things around rather than three months, we will lose. It is that simple.
The money will continue to dry up. Talk of a deal with Reform will only increase. But what incentive does Farage have to agree to one? His boot is on our throats. As his ratings reach the high 20s and ours dip into the teens, you don’t have to play around with Electoral Calculus before he gains a majority and we are left with under 50 MPs. We still have much, much further to fall.
More importantly, Reform’s whole USP is that they are not part of the failing, disgraced, uniparty establishment. A deal with us would not only spare a party that Farage has spent thirty years campaigning against and is on the verge of replacing. It would be a repudiation of his voters, members, and MPs. He has no reason to throw us a life raft but will enjoy watching us drown.
If a deal were to happen, it would have to be in Reform’s interest. They would have to be on the back foot, declining in the polls, and under pressure from a resurgent Conservative Party. A few more screw-ups like their ludicrous Net Zero announcements might take the sheen of them. Is that the best Badenoch can hope for? To put her faith in Farage proving worse at leading than her?
She might change. She might improve. As McTague highlights, Margaret Thatcher’s early days were hardly met with rave reviews. Her indefinite leave to remain announcement showed that the “no policies until 2027” approach is already wilting under the pressure of events. Perhaps the focus groups are being listened to. Stop the freeze peach chatter, and start talking to voters.
But as I speak to MPs and other senior figures, there isn’t much hope. Politics is being played at ten times speed. Babbling about principles until party conference will not attract the donors, members, or optimism that we desperately require. As myself, the inestimable Tom Jones, and an increasing number are saying, this is our endgame – the death spasms of 300 years of Toryism.
Which is why the most pressing question about Badenoch’s leadership has already shifted from if she will go before the next election to when – and who replaces her. I had expected that she would have until next year’s local, Scottish, and Welsh elections before she would be in serious trouble. But the timescale keeps shortening. She might not make it to the end of the summer.
In which case, who next? James Cleverly, who deftly avoided serving under her, and who wouldn’t frighten the horses? Robert Jenrick, for whom members already seem to have developed buyer’s remorse, as he plays the Mayor of the Palace to Badenoch’s late Merovingian? Or Boris Johnson, to whom eyes always always turn in a crisis, and in whose direction madness lies?
The latter is blunted by being outside of the Commons. But the usual chorus has already struck up. Whoever would replace Badenoch, their only strategy would have to be total media saturation, the adoption of those policies on migration that thoughtful Conservatives have long since put out there, and a studious attempt to blunt Farage’s momentum. Anything else is suicide.
Could it work? Who can say? But if Badenoch doesn’t want her MPs to take that gamble, she will have to save her ailing leadership, and fast. Our fourth leadership election in three years is not a prospect that fills me with delight. But if Badenoch had consulted with Hague, he would have reminded her that this party is an absolute monarchy, moderated by regicide. Cue the Dire Straits.
Badeonoch must prove that she wants to fight, fight, and fight to save a party she loves. Or her leadership – and the Conservative Party – is doomed.