K Harvey Proctor was MP for Basildon from 1979 to 1983 and for Billericay from 1983 to 1987. He is President, Facing Allegations in Contexts of Trust (FACT).
Apparently, in the eyes of the Ministry of Justice, I am not a victim. I am merely someone who has been “described as having been falsely accused of a crime”.
Those are the Government’s words, not mine. They expose an extraordinary indifference to those whose lives and reputations have been devastated by deliberate, malicious and criminal false allegations.
I am grateful to Labour MP Alex Mayer, who asked the Justice Secretary what assessment had been made of the impact of the Victims and Courts Act 2026 on people falsely accused of serious crimes.
The response from Justice Minister Alex Davies-Jones was as revealing as it was infuriating:
“No separate assessment was made of people described as having been falsely accused of a crime.”
An astonishing admission.
The Government has considered the rights of defendants and offenders, but has made no separate assessment of those whose lives have been destroyed by criminal falsehoods.
I know the consequences only too well.
Carl Beech falsely accused me, former Conservative Prime Minister Sir Edward Heath, D-Day veteran and former Chief of the Defence Staff Lord Bramall, and former Conservative Home Secretary Lord Leon Brittan of the most heinous crimes imaginable.
I was accused of serial child murder and the sexual abuse of children. The resulting Operation Midland investigation cost me my home, my livelihood and my reputation. I received credible death threats which, at the behest of the police, forced me to move home twice.
Beech was subsequently convicted of perverting the course of justice and sentenced to 18 years’ imprisonment. Yet he was released after serving approximately 40 per cent of that sentence.
I was not even informed. Neither were the families of Lord Bramall, Sir Edward Heath or Lord Brittan.
Why? Because, under the legal framework applied to my case, the Crown was treated as the victim of perverting the course of justice, while those whose lives Beech sought to destroy were denied the recognition and notification rights they deserved.
It is a grotesque injustice.
In her parliamentary response, Davies-Jones acknowledged that deliberately making false allegations can constitute perverting the course of justice or wasting police time.
So the Government recognises the crime and the criminal, yet cannot recognise those directly harmed as victims entitled to information and protection.
What extraordinary moral and legal contortions.
Alongside Lady Diana Brittan, the family of Lord Bramall and the Sir Edward Heath Charitable Foundation, I previously wrote to David Lammy seeking clarification about whether the new legislation would finally address this injustice.
We received assurances about extending information rights to more victims, but no answer to the central question.
Now, under Alex Norris – to whom we have written with the support of Sir Cliff Richard – the Ministry of Justice continues the same old obfuscation.
But this is not solely a matter for the Government. It is time for the Conservative Party to find its voice.
The Conservatives have long prided themselves on being the party of law and order. From Sir Robert Peel’s commitment to the rule of law and the establishment of modern policing to Margaret Thatcher’s insistence that justice and public safety are fundamental responsibilities of government, protecting the innocent has been central to Conservative principles.
Yet what does law and order mean if the law fails to recognise those whose lives have been deliberately destroyed by criminal accusations?
Among those falsely accused by Beech were a former Conservative Prime Minister, a former Conservative Home Secretary and one of Britain’s most distinguished military commanders. Their public service did not spare them from the devastating consequences of malicious falsehoods.
Nor should their distinguished positions entitle them to protections denied to anyone else. This campaign is about justice for every innocent person maliciously accused of serious crime, regardless of background, profession or political allegiance.
I therefore call upon Kemi Badenoch, as Leader of the Conservative Party, to give this campaign her unequivocal support and press the Government to close this glaring gap in victims’ rights.
The Conservative Party should lead the charge for reform, not watch from the sidelines.
If someone deliberately fabricates allegations of murder and child sexual abuse, destroys innocent lives and is convicted of perverting the course of justice, surely those directly targeted should be recognised as victims and informed when their tormentor is released from prison.
The Victims and Courts Act 2026 offered an opportunity to confront this injustice. Instead, the Government admits it did not undertake a separate assessment of those falsely accused.
I ask Alex Norris a simple question: Will the Government ensure that victims of malicious false allegations are recognised in law and afforded appropriate rights to information and protection, or will it continue to treat the Crown as the only victim?
And I ask Kemi Badenoch to stand with us and demand an answer.
Lord Bramall and Lord Brittan are no longer here to defend their reputations. Their families deserve justice. So do the family and supporters of Sir Edward Heath. So do I.
The Conservative Party has a proud tradition of defending the rule of law. Here is an opportunity to demonstrate that those principles are more than a political slogan.
A justice system that recognises the criminal offence but overlooks the innocent people devastated by it is a justice system in urgent need of reform.
It is time for the Conservatives to champion these forgotten victims and back this reform.
Apparently, in the eyes of the Ministry of Justice, I am not a victim. I am merely someone who has been “described as having been falsely accused of a crime”.
Those are the Government’s words, not mine. They expose an extraordinary indifference to those whose lives and reputations have been devastated by deliberate, malicious and criminal false allegations.
I am grateful to Labour MP Alex Mayer, who asked the Justice Secretary what assessment had been made of the impact of the Victims and Courts Act 2026 on people falsely accused of serious crimes.
The response from Justice Minister Alex Davies-Jones was as revealing as it was infuriating:
“No separate assessment was made of people described as having been falsely accused of a crime.”
An astonishing admission.
The Government has considered the rights of defendants and offenders, but has made no separate assessment of those whose lives have been destroyed by criminal falsehoods.
I know the consequences only too well.
Carl Beech falsely accused me, former Conservative Prime Minister Sir Edward Heath, D-Day veteran and former Chief of the Defence Staff Lord Bramall, and former Conservative Home Secretary Lord Leon Brittan of the most heinous crimes imaginable.
I was accused of serial child murder and the sexual abuse of children. The resulting Operation Midland investigation cost me my home, my livelihood and my reputation. I received credible death threats which, at the behest of the police, forced me to move home twice.
Beech was subsequently convicted of perverting the course of justice and sentenced to 18 years’ imprisonment. Yet he was released after serving approximately 40 per cent of that sentence.
I was not even informed. Neither were the families of Lord Bramall, Sir Edward Heath or Lord Brittan.
Why? Because, under the legal framework applied to my case, the Crown was treated as the victim of perverting the course of justice, while those whose lives Beech sought to destroy were denied the recognition and notification rights they deserved.
It is a grotesque injustice.
In her parliamentary response, Davies-Jones acknowledged that deliberately making false allegations can constitute perverting the course of justice or wasting police time.
So the Government recognises the crime and the criminal, yet cannot recognise those directly harmed as victims entitled to information and protection.
What extraordinary moral and legal contortions.
Alongside Lady Diana Brittan, the family of Lord Bramall and the Sir Edward Heath Charitable Foundation, I previously wrote to David Lammy seeking clarification about whether the new legislation would finally address this injustice.
We received assurances about extending information rights to more victims, but no answer to the central question.
Now, under Alex Norris – to whom we have written with the support of Sir Cliff Richard – the Ministry of Justice continues the same old obfuscation.
But this is not solely a matter for the Government. It is time for the Conservative Party to find its voice.
The Conservatives have long prided themselves on being the party of law and order. From Sir Robert Peel’s commitment to the rule of law and the establishment of modern policing to Margaret Thatcher’s insistence that justice and public safety are fundamental responsibilities of government, protecting the innocent has been central to Conservative principles.
Yet what does law and order mean if the law fails to recognise those whose lives have been deliberately destroyed by criminal accusations?
Among those falsely accused by Beech were a former Conservative Prime Minister, a former Conservative Home Secretary and one of Britain’s most distinguished military commanders. Their public service did not spare them from the devastating consequences of malicious falsehoods.
Nor should their distinguished positions entitle them to protections denied to anyone else. This campaign is about justice for every innocent person maliciously accused of serious crime, regardless of background, profession or political allegiance.
I therefore call upon Kemi Badenoch, as Leader of the Conservative Party, to give this campaign her unequivocal support and press the Government to close this glaring gap in victims’ rights.
The Conservative Party should lead the charge for reform, not watch from the sidelines.
If someone deliberately fabricates allegations of murder and child sexual abuse, destroys innocent lives and is convicted of perverting the course of justice, surely those directly targeted should be recognised as victims and informed when their tormentor is released from prison.
The Victims and Courts Act 2026 offered an opportunity to confront this injustice. Instead, the Government admits it did not undertake a separate assessment of those falsely accused.
I ask Alex Norris a simple question: Will the Government ensure that victims of malicious false allegations are recognised in law and afforded appropriate rights to information and protection, or will it continue to treat the Crown as the only victim?
And I ask Kemi Badenoch to stand with us and demand an answer.
Lord Bramall and Lord Brittan are no longer here to defend their reputations. Their families deserve justice. So do the family and supporters of Sir Edward Heath. So do I.
The Conservative Party has a proud tradition of defending the rule of law. Here is an opportunity to demonstrate that those principles are more than a political slogan.
A justice system that recognises the criminal offence but overlooks the innocent people devastated by it is a justice system in urgent need of reform.
It is time for the Conservatives to champion these forgotten victims and back this reform.