Charles Amos teaches political theory and conducts original social research. He writes The Musing Individualist Substack in his spare time.
Individuals in love are often blind to reality and, on many occasions, choose their spouse unwisely as a result. Crucially, individuals themselves are aware of this in advance. Marriage rights today are not transferable: However, by legally allowing adult children to pre-emptively transfer some or all of their marriage rights to their parents, mothers and fathers could veto unwise spousal choices. This is the liberal solution which recognises people should always be free in this intimate realm, but that many people are ruled by their passions and are not very likely to make wise choices.
Many marriages are more likely to go wrong than not and we know this by looking at the divorce rate of different groups. Women married before the age of 20 have a 53 per cent of divorcing before their 30th wedding anniversary compared to just 23 per cent for those women marrying between the ages of 30 and 34. The divorce rate for same sex, married couples is 19.5 per 1,000 compared to a much smaller 8.4 per 1,000 for opposite sex couples.
US Census Data shows people married to casino managers have the highest divorce rate at 53 per cent compared to those married to actuaries at 17 per cent, all against a baseline of about 36 per cent. Besides broad statistical trends, however, many parents will just know their children will not get on with their chosen partner. General trends and parental knowledge present the possibility to improve the expected wellbeing of children by moving them from high risk partners to low risk partners.
Adult children should be free to sell or give away some or all of their marriage, cohabitation and reproductive rights to their parents, or, marriage rights holding companies, so they can veto unions which are likely to be against the best interest of the prospective partners. This would force prospective partners into better unions thus increasing their long term wellbeing, and, ensure they are only selected to begin with from good criteria.
Again, the great problem with love and sexual desire is that it blinds people to objective reality by creating too rosy a view of their prospective partner. This is particularly so for those with low impulse control who might jump into marriage or reproduction recklessly at 24 years old, who, under this scheme, might not be allowed to, having sold their marriage rates to their parents at 18 for £1,000 (until they’re 27 when they’re returned, for example).
They’d have sold their marriage rights, because, like most people, they’re aware that love can blind them to rational calculation. Parents, on the other hand, are not so blinded. The children, aware of this, might sell or give away certain marriage rights off the bat, or, parents might kick off the process by trying to buy them.
No doubt there will be a lot of objections to this marketisation of marriage rights. All are questionable. Surely parents bringing lawsuits against their children will spoil parental relationships beyond repair? Maybe. The solution to this is the marriage rights holding company (MRHC). A parent buys a certain set of rights off their children at 16 (e.g., no marriage before 25 and none at all with casino managers, former drug addicts, or, those with a history of domestic violence) and then alienate said marriage rights to a MRHC which would bring the legal case should it transpire. No anger would result between parents and children since the vetoing would be out of the hands of the parents.
The existence of MRHCs would overcome the difficulty of enforcing contracts too because the MRHCs could have very detailed default contracts already drawn up and have an inhouse adjudicator. All of this would reduce what Ronald Coase calls the transaction costs of making and enforcing a contract by effectively turning its administration into an intrafirm procedure. Other arrangements such as a husband buying off his wife’s future marriage rights to protect his sons’ inheritance could also be offered – the possibilities are endless.
Should adult children not like their parents holding their marriage rights at all, MRHCs could directly buy or keep for free their marriage rights. Where would MRHCs get the money to pay off the children?
Two points. First, should young adults recognise it is in their self-interest to give up some of their marriage rights, they’ll do so for free. Second, should this not be so, MRHCs could raise revenue by selling the marriage rights back at a large markup. For example, people who really want to marry at 21 but who don’t have such rights until they are 25 could buy back their rights.
This would act as a good test of genuine belief in compatibility with your partner too, because you wouldn’t take out a £10,000 loan from the MRHC without it. Would all this just be circumvented by people cohabiting and having children out of wedlock? There is no reason why MHRCs should not have acquired rights to veto such arrangements too, vetos which could be effectively applied by imposing large fines for breaches; fine revenue, again, going to pay for the initial buy offs.
I suspect many people will object to the very idea of selling marriage rights. Why? If it is because it is not in the self-interest of the seller, then, two things can be said. One, this is a very contingent reason to be against it as MRHCs might help produce better marriages; indeed, they’d be in competition to produce the best packages for people, assisted by whole departments of social scientists, actuaries and AI date analysts looking at you and general trends.
Second, people should be free to make mistakes anyway. I suspect others will still object to the reduction in autonomy though. Although autonomy is valuable it is not something which should never be allowed to be traded off against other goods. We accept people should be allowed to sterilise themselves, run up student debt and commit suicide, all of which limit our future choices, so, why can’t the individual limit their future choices by selling their marriages rights too.
Marriage rights should be transferable such that wise parents or statistically well informed marriage rights holding companies can veto poor choices of spouses. As well as recognising individuals should be free to alienate their rights as well as exercise them, this proposal would significantly improve the wellbeing of people with poor foresight by stopping them marrying on the basis of lust or a fundamental misunderstanding as to compatibility.
As we are free to marry whoever we want today, irrespective of sex, race or creed, so we should be free to be stopped from marrying whoever we want too.
Charles Amos teaches political theory and conducts original social research. He writes The Musing Individualist Substack in his spare time.
Individuals in love are often blind to reality and, on many occasions, choose their spouse unwisely as a result. Crucially, individuals themselves are aware of this in advance. Marriage rights today are not transferable: However, by legally allowing adult children to pre-emptively transfer some or all of their marriage rights to their parents, mothers and fathers could veto unwise spousal choices. This is the liberal solution which recognises people should always be free in this intimate realm, but that many people are ruled by their passions and are not very likely to make wise choices.
Many marriages are more likely to go wrong than not and we know this by looking at the divorce rate of different groups. Women married before the age of 20 have a 53 per cent of divorcing before their 30th wedding anniversary compared to just 23 per cent for those women marrying between the ages of 30 and 34. The divorce rate for same sex, married couples is 19.5 per 1,000 compared to a much smaller 8.4 per 1,000 for opposite sex couples.
US Census Data shows people married to casino managers have the highest divorce rate at 53 per cent compared to those married to actuaries at 17 per cent, all against a baseline of about 36 per cent. Besides broad statistical trends, however, many parents will just know their children will not get on with their chosen partner. General trends and parental knowledge present the possibility to improve the expected wellbeing of children by moving them from high risk partners to low risk partners.
Adult children should be free to sell or give away some or all of their marriage, cohabitation and reproductive rights to their parents, or, marriage rights holding companies, so they can veto unions which are likely to be against the best interest of the prospective partners. This would force prospective partners into better unions thus increasing their long term wellbeing, and, ensure they are only selected to begin with from good criteria.
Again, the great problem with love and sexual desire is that it blinds people to objective reality by creating too rosy a view of their prospective partner. This is particularly so for those with low impulse control who might jump into marriage or reproduction recklessly at 24 years old, who, under this scheme, might not be allowed to, having sold their marriage rates to their parents at 18 for £1,000 (until they’re 27 when they’re returned, for example).
They’d have sold their marriage rights, because, like most people, they’re aware that love can blind them to rational calculation. Parents, on the other hand, are not so blinded. The children, aware of this, might sell or give away certain marriage rights off the bat, or, parents might kick off the process by trying to buy them.
No doubt there will be a lot of objections to this marketisation of marriage rights. All are questionable. Surely parents bringing lawsuits against their children will spoil parental relationships beyond repair? Maybe. The solution to this is the marriage rights holding company (MRHC). A parent buys a certain set of rights off their children at 16 (e.g., no marriage before 25 and none at all with casino managers, former drug addicts, or, those with a history of domestic violence) and then alienate said marriage rights to a MRHC which would bring the legal case should it transpire. No anger would result between parents and children since the vetoing would be out of the hands of the parents.
The existence of MRHCs would overcome the difficulty of enforcing contracts too because the MRHCs could have very detailed default contracts already drawn up and have an inhouse adjudicator. All of this would reduce what Ronald Coase calls the transaction costs of making and enforcing a contract by effectively turning its administration into an intrafirm procedure. Other arrangements such as a husband buying off his wife’s future marriage rights to protect his sons’ inheritance could also be offered – the possibilities are endless.
Should adult children not like their parents holding their marriage rights at all, MRHCs could directly buy or keep for free their marriage rights. Where would MRHCs get the money to pay off the children?
Two points. First, should young adults recognise it is in their self-interest to give up some of their marriage rights, they’ll do so for free. Second, should this not be so, MRHCs could raise revenue by selling the marriage rights back at a large markup. For example, people who really want to marry at 21 but who don’t have such rights until they are 25 could buy back their rights.
This would act as a good test of genuine belief in compatibility with your partner too, because you wouldn’t take out a £10,000 loan from the MRHC without it. Would all this just be circumvented by people cohabiting and having children out of wedlock? There is no reason why MHRCs should not have acquired rights to veto such arrangements too, vetos which could be effectively applied by imposing large fines for breaches; fine revenue, again, going to pay for the initial buy offs.
I suspect many people will object to the very idea of selling marriage rights. Why? If it is because it is not in the self-interest of the seller, then, two things can be said. One, this is a very contingent reason to be against it as MRHCs might help produce better marriages; indeed, they’d be in competition to produce the best packages for people, assisted by whole departments of social scientists, actuaries and AI date analysts looking at you and general trends.
Second, people should be free to make mistakes anyway. I suspect others will still object to the reduction in autonomy though. Although autonomy is valuable it is not something which should never be allowed to be traded off against other goods. We accept people should be allowed to sterilise themselves, run up student debt and commit suicide, all of which limit our future choices, so, why can’t the individual limit their future choices by selling their marriages rights too.
Marriage rights should be transferable such that wise parents or statistically well informed marriage rights holding companies can veto poor choices of spouses. As well as recognising individuals should be free to alienate their rights as well as exercise them, this proposal would significantly improve the wellbeing of people with poor foresight by stopping them marrying on the basis of lust or a fundamental misunderstanding as to compatibility.
As we are free to marry whoever we want today, irrespective of sex, race or creed, so we should be free to be stopped from marrying whoever we want too.