Dr Reva Gudi is GP and healthcare leader in Hayes, Middlesex, she is also a former Conservative parliamentary candidate, and serves as a local school governor and charity trustee.
I’ll call him Sam. He isn’t one patient. He is representative of many young people I have seen and everything in this story I have seen many times.
It begins with the first consultation. Sam is nineteen. He comes in with his mother, who does most of the talking. He sits, turned away, with his thumb on the phone he isn’t looking at.
I offer his mother the option of waiting outside, remembering how I felt at his age with my parents in the room and they accept. Sam left college six months ago. He says that “the course wasn’t right” and that he’ll find something else.
Not only is he not sleeping well, but his answers are short. However, he makes eye contact, and when I ask what he’d like to do, he has an answer. Something with cars, maybe. There is still a young man in the room with plans, even if he is a little lost.
Three months later, Sam comes on his own. The answers are shorter than before and the gaps between them longer.
In general practice we learn to listen to silences. Some are thinking. Some are embarrassment. And some, the ones I have come to dread in young people, are the silence of someone who has stopped expecting the conversation to lead anywhere, and who believes nothing is expected of them.
There is no mention of cars now. He has sent off a few job applications and has heard nothing back. His friends are mostly at work or university, and he doesn’t really see them. He feels low and asks whether I can write something to say he isn’t well enough to work.
By the time of the third consultation, Sam barely looks up. This time his mother has told the receptionist she is worried.
What strikes me is how much he has shrunk. He appears anxious and low. We know confidence is built in small daily ways: getting up for something, being expected somewhere, managing a conversation with a stranger. So is resilience. We learn to cope with setbacks by meeting them, a difficult assignment or a telling -off by a manager and finding that we get through.
Sam has had none of those for months, and each week without them makes the next week harder to contemplate.
Yet he still talks to me. People tell their GP things they would hesitate to tell a work coach, because I can’t stop their money. That trust is precious, and it is often the only open door they have left.
Sam is not alone. According to the Milburn review nearly a million 16 to 24-year-olds, more than one in eight, are now not in education, employment or training (NEET). The proportion of these young people reporting a work-limiting health condition has risen by 70 per cent over the past decade, and six in ten have never had a job at all.
It would be easy to judge Sam. People do. Relatives ask what he is doing with himself, and neighbours notice that he is always at home. Each question confirms what he already feels: that he has failed, and that everyone can see it.
So, he withdraws further. The friends he still talks to, mostly online, are in the same position. There is comfort in that, but also a trap. When everyone around you is stuck too, it starts to feel normal, even like a kind of belonging.
Then there is the benefits system. It is there to support Sam, and it should. But to qualify for health-related support, he must describe himself in terms of what he cannot do. Each form and each assessment asks him to set out his limitations. Over time, that risks becoming the story he tells about himself. A system designed to support him may inadvertently reinforce the very limitations he needs help to overcome.
There are expectations, but I would argue the expectations within the system are weak, poorly enforced and rarely matched by meaningful opportunities or outcomes. The benefit stops being a bridge back to work and becomes something to hold on to. Losing it feels riskier than staying put, and dependency sets in quietly, without Sam having intended it.
Late at night he scrolls through his friends’ lives online: new jobs, nights out, lots of photos. I sense bitterness, at himself and at a world that has moved on without him, and sometimes a sense of entitlement, a feeling that something is owed. I don’t see that as a flaw in his character. It is perhaps what happens when, month after month, you are faced with rejected applications or the only thing asked of you is to describe what you cannot do, rather than what you can.
And yet almost every young person I have met like Sam wants to work, study and make something of their lives. What they lack is a way back in.
The difference between a young person who finds that way back and one who doesn’t often comes down to one phone call.
Some young people have a parent who will ring a cousin with a business, chase the college or call in a favour. Many of the young people I see come from homes where nobody can make that call. Their parents may be working long hours, unwell themselves, unfamiliar with the system or simply without the contacts. It isn’t a lack of love. It’s a lack of reach.
On this site, Ben Gadsby recently made the case for reaching out to young people who are missing from the system altogether, and for separating support from sanctions. From my consulting room, I couldn’t agree more. Milburn proposes that a health-related benefit claim should automatically trigger an offer of support from the Youth Opportunity Service. I would go further. Every young person should be referred at the time of making the first claim and expected to take up support so that the first conversation is a proper one, with the right people, about what is possible. And for young people who have no one else to make that first phone call, the Youth Opportunity Service must make it, and make it quickly.
Sam doesn’t need another sick note. He needs someone to say that, “there is a place for you on Monday. I’ll see you there.”
I welcome the rationale and recommendations within the Milburn Review. But this is a national emergency. Reviews take months. Legislation takes years. Implementation takes longer still. Sam has weeks. And without action, Milburn warns, one in six young people, a quarter of a million more, will be where Sam is within five years.
So, can we afford to wait for governments to get their act together? Any of us can make the first phone call: the employer who offers a week’s work experience, the business taking a chance on a patchy CV, the charity, faith group, sports club or family friend who says, “come in on Monday.”
So can those of us in surgeries, schools and councils who notice the signs. A stimulating job or training environment, that expects something of them, even for a few weeks, can change a young person’s direction. This isn’t a task for the state alone. It never was.
Young people bring energy, enthusiasm and an appetite for life. In my own practice, we offer young people work experience and first jobs, whether or not they go on to a career in healthcare. There is nothing more rewarding than seeing our young people with a sense of purpose, heads held high and full of plans.
In young people like Sam, that spark doesn’t disappear. It goes quiet, often waiting for someone to notice. Somewhere beneath the silence Sam still wants to work with cars. If we act now, before the silences grow longer, we will hear that young man again.
Dr Reva Gudi is GP and healthcare leader in Hayes, Middlesex, she is also a former Conservative parliamentary candidate, and serves as a local school governor and charity trustee.
I’ll call him Sam. He isn’t one patient. He is representative of many young people I have seen and everything in this story I have seen many times.
It begins with the first consultation. Sam is nineteen. He comes in with his mother, who does most of the talking. He sits, turned away, with his thumb on the phone he isn’t looking at.
I offer his mother the option of waiting outside, remembering how I felt at his age with my parents in the room and they accept. Sam left college six months ago. He says that “the course wasn’t right” and that he’ll find something else.
Not only is he not sleeping well, but his answers are short. However, he makes eye contact, and when I ask what he’d like to do, he has an answer. Something with cars, maybe. There is still a young man in the room with plans, even if he is a little lost.
Three months later, Sam comes on his own. The answers are shorter than before and the gaps between them longer.
In general practice we learn to listen to silences. Some are thinking. Some are embarrassment. And some, the ones I have come to dread in young people, are the silence of someone who has stopped expecting the conversation to lead anywhere, and who believes nothing is expected of them.
There is no mention of cars now. He has sent off a few job applications and has heard nothing back. His friends are mostly at work or university, and he doesn’t really see them. He feels low and asks whether I can write something to say he isn’t well enough to work.
By the time of the third consultation, Sam barely looks up. This time his mother has told the receptionist she is worried.
What strikes me is how much he has shrunk. He appears anxious and low. We know confidence is built in small daily ways: getting up for something, being expected somewhere, managing a conversation with a stranger. So is resilience. We learn to cope with setbacks by meeting them, a difficult assignment or a telling -off by a manager and finding that we get through.
Sam has had none of those for months, and each week without them makes the next week harder to contemplate.
Yet he still talks to me. People tell their GP things they would hesitate to tell a work coach, because I can’t stop their money. That trust is precious, and it is often the only open door they have left.
Sam is not alone. According to the Milburn review nearly a million 16 to 24-year-olds, more than one in eight, are now not in education, employment or training (NEET). The proportion of these young people reporting a work-limiting health condition has risen by 70 per cent over the past decade, and six in ten have never had a job at all.
It would be easy to judge Sam. People do. Relatives ask what he is doing with himself, and neighbours notice that he is always at home. Each question confirms what he already feels: that he has failed, and that everyone can see it.
So, he withdraws further. The friends he still talks to, mostly online, are in the same position. There is comfort in that, but also a trap. When everyone around you is stuck too, it starts to feel normal, even like a kind of belonging.
Then there is the benefits system. It is there to support Sam, and it should. But to qualify for health-related support, he must describe himself in terms of what he cannot do. Each form and each assessment asks him to set out his limitations. Over time, that risks becoming the story he tells about himself. A system designed to support him may inadvertently reinforce the very limitations he needs help to overcome.
There are expectations, but I would argue the expectations within the system are weak, poorly enforced and rarely matched by meaningful opportunities or outcomes. The benefit stops being a bridge back to work and becomes something to hold on to. Losing it feels riskier than staying put, and dependency sets in quietly, without Sam having intended it.
Late at night he scrolls through his friends’ lives online: new jobs, nights out, lots of photos. I sense bitterness, at himself and at a world that has moved on without him, and sometimes a sense of entitlement, a feeling that something is owed. I don’t see that as a flaw in his character. It is perhaps what happens when, month after month, you are faced with rejected applications or the only thing asked of you is to describe what you cannot do, rather than what you can.
And yet almost every young person I have met like Sam wants to work, study and make something of their lives. What they lack is a way back in.
The difference between a young person who finds that way back and one who doesn’t often comes down to one phone call.
Some young people have a parent who will ring a cousin with a business, chase the college or call in a favour. Many of the young people I see come from homes where nobody can make that call. Their parents may be working long hours, unwell themselves, unfamiliar with the system or simply without the contacts. It isn’t a lack of love. It’s a lack of reach.
On this site, Ben Gadsby recently made the case for reaching out to young people who are missing from the system altogether, and for separating support from sanctions. From my consulting room, I couldn’t agree more. Milburn proposes that a health-related benefit claim should automatically trigger an offer of support from the Youth Opportunity Service. I would go further. Every young person should be referred at the time of making the first claim and expected to take up support so that the first conversation is a proper one, with the right people, about what is possible. And for young people who have no one else to make that first phone call, the Youth Opportunity Service must make it, and make it quickly.
Sam doesn’t need another sick note. He needs someone to say that, “there is a place for you on Monday. I’ll see you there.”
I welcome the rationale and recommendations within the Milburn Review. But this is a national emergency. Reviews take months. Legislation takes years. Implementation takes longer still. Sam has weeks. And without action, Milburn warns, one in six young people, a quarter of a million more, will be where Sam is within five years.
So, can we afford to wait for governments to get their act together? Any of us can make the first phone call: the employer who offers a week’s work experience, the business taking a chance on a patchy CV, the charity, faith group, sports club or family friend who says, “come in on Monday.”
So can those of us in surgeries, schools and councils who notice the signs. A stimulating job or training environment, that expects something of them, even for a few weeks, can change a young person’s direction. This isn’t a task for the state alone. It never was.
Young people bring energy, enthusiasm and an appetite for life. In my own practice, we offer young people work experience and first jobs, whether or not they go on to a career in healthcare. There is nothing more rewarding than seeing our young people with a sense of purpose, heads held high and full of plans.
In young people like Sam, that spark doesn’t disappear. It goes quiet, often waiting for someone to notice. Somewhere beneath the silence Sam still wants to work with cars. If we act now, before the silences grow longer, we will hear that young man again.