Kate Coleman is the Director of Keep Prisons Single Sex.
At the end of January this year, Adam Graham was found guilty of two counts of rape at the High Court in Glasgow. Bail was revoked and he was remanded to prison to await sentencing.
According to Scottish Government statistics, from 2021 to 2022 there were just under 2,500 crimes of rape or attempted rape recorded by Police Scotland.
These figures demonstrate that rape is by no means an unusual crime: Graham’s conviction should have been straightforwardly reported as yet another incidence of a shocking and regrettably all too commonplace event.
Events played out very differently. Shortly after being charged, Graham had begun to identify as a woman, finally settling on the name Isla Bryson. The photos of Bryson outside court prior to conviction are now familiar: a bottle-blonde wig angled to cover extensive facial tattoos; maroon leggings clearly showing the outline of intact male genitalia.
As far as the criminal justice system was concerned it was not Adam Graham who was tried at court, convicted and sent to prison. It was Isla Bryson.
At some point after leaving court, having been found guilty of crimes committed “when she was a man”, the initial decision to send him to the male estate at Barlinnie was overturned, and this convicted double rapist was sent, after the involvement of the Scottish Prison Service HQ, to the female estate at Cornton Vale.
There was a public outcry, with media reports throughout the United Kingdom. After sustained political pressure – with Scottish Conservative and Unionist MSPs taking a leading role – the Scottish Government made a telephone call to Scottish Prison Service HQ outlining ministerial concerns.
Eventually, Graham/Bryson was transferred to the male estate, where he is believed to remain.
In the aftermath, an Urgent Lessons Learned Review was commissioned and on February 22 Teresa Medhurst, CEO of the Scottish Prison Service, and Keith Brown, the then Justice Secretary, were called to give evidence before the Criminal Justice Committee.
Yet the review remained shrouded in secrecy: the report was not published, and those who commissioned, undertook, and oversaw the review determined that not even the members of the Criminal Justice Committee should be permitted to read it.
Speaking in convoluted “managerialese”, Medhurst and Brown presented a confusing and confused tangle of initial preventative measures, further measures to be stipulated in a still-to-be-written Standard Operating Procedure, and recommendations to be fed into the wider policy review. The only statements made with any certainty were those expressing their confidence in Scottish Prison Service policy and practice.
Whilst the SNP Cabinet and the Scottish Prison Service continued to tie themselves in knots, the Ministry of Justice issued their revised policy on the care and management of transgender prisoners in England and Wales.
This states that no male prisoner serving a sentence for any violent or sexual offence may be held in the general population of the female estate, and that no male prisoner with intact male genitalia, regardless of conviction, may be housed alongside women.
Exceptions will only be considered if there is a high level of confidence that only a low risk of harm will be posed, and require ministerial sign off. Significantly, these stipulations apply equally and in the same way to both prisoners with and without a gender recognition certificate.
These are important shifts. This policy now places risk to female offenders and their safety right at its centre: women’s need for safety is no longer something that may easily be disregarded.
Such changes, arguably only feasible under a Tory government, are policy firsts. My hope is that other departments, health and education in particular, will follow suit.
At the time of the Bryson review, the Scottish Government stated that five male prisoners were held in women’s prisons, all serving lengthy sentences for violent offences. Yet in March it was reported that the number of male prisoners held in the female estate was now seven – all imprisoned for violent offences.
Whilst it is unclear how many of these have been sent to the female estate subsequent to the Bryson review, what is clear is that the new Ministry of Justice policy would see all seven relocated to men’s prisons.
Scotland now has a new First Minister following his election as SNP party leader. The cabinet has also changed, with Angela Constance appointed as Cabinet Secretary for Justice.
Just as I hope that other departments in Westminster will take inspiration from the Ministry of Justice, I trust that the Scottish Government and Scottish Prison Service will also look to the measures this policy puts in place and see them as the minimum standard for protecting women in prison.
I suspect, however, that Scottish Tory MSPs will need to keep up the pressure.
Kate Coleman is the Director of Keep Prisons Single Sex.
At the end of January this year, Adam Graham was found guilty of two counts of rape at the High Court in Glasgow. Bail was revoked and he was remanded to prison to await sentencing.
According to Scottish Government statistics, from 2021 to 2022 there were just under 2,500 crimes of rape or attempted rape recorded by Police Scotland.
These figures demonstrate that rape is by no means an unusual crime: Graham’s conviction should have been straightforwardly reported as yet another incidence of a shocking and regrettably all too commonplace event.
Events played out very differently. Shortly after being charged, Graham had begun to identify as a woman, finally settling on the name Isla Bryson. The photos of Bryson outside court prior to conviction are now familiar: a bottle-blonde wig angled to cover extensive facial tattoos; maroon leggings clearly showing the outline of intact male genitalia.
As far as the criminal justice system was concerned it was not Adam Graham who was tried at court, convicted and sent to prison. It was Isla Bryson.
At some point after leaving court, having been found guilty of crimes committed “when she was a man”, the initial decision to send him to the male estate at Barlinnie was overturned, and this convicted double rapist was sent, after the involvement of the Scottish Prison Service HQ, to the female estate at Cornton Vale.
There was a public outcry, with media reports throughout the United Kingdom. After sustained political pressure – with Scottish Conservative and Unionist MSPs taking a leading role – the Scottish Government made a telephone call to Scottish Prison Service HQ outlining ministerial concerns.
Eventually, Graham/Bryson was transferred to the male estate, where he is believed to remain.
In the aftermath, an Urgent Lessons Learned Review was commissioned and on February 22 Teresa Medhurst, CEO of the Scottish Prison Service, and Keith Brown, the then Justice Secretary, were called to give evidence before the Criminal Justice Committee.
Yet the review remained shrouded in secrecy: the report was not published, and those who commissioned, undertook, and oversaw the review determined that not even the members of the Criminal Justice Committee should be permitted to read it.
Speaking in convoluted “managerialese”, Medhurst and Brown presented a confusing and confused tangle of initial preventative measures, further measures to be stipulated in a still-to-be-written Standard Operating Procedure, and recommendations to be fed into the wider policy review. The only statements made with any certainty were those expressing their confidence in Scottish Prison Service policy and practice.
Whilst the SNP Cabinet and the Scottish Prison Service continued to tie themselves in knots, the Ministry of Justice issued their revised policy on the care and management of transgender prisoners in England and Wales.
This states that no male prisoner serving a sentence for any violent or sexual offence may be held in the general population of the female estate, and that no male prisoner with intact male genitalia, regardless of conviction, may be housed alongside women.
Exceptions will only be considered if there is a high level of confidence that only a low risk of harm will be posed, and require ministerial sign off. Significantly, these stipulations apply equally and in the same way to both prisoners with and without a gender recognition certificate.
These are important shifts. This policy now places risk to female offenders and their safety right at its centre: women’s need for safety is no longer something that may easily be disregarded.
Such changes, arguably only feasible under a Tory government, are policy firsts. My hope is that other departments, health and education in particular, will follow suit.
At the time of the Bryson review, the Scottish Government stated that five male prisoners were held in women’s prisons, all serving lengthy sentences for violent offences. Yet in March it was reported that the number of male prisoners held in the female estate was now seven – all imprisoned for violent offences.
Whilst it is unclear how many of these have been sent to the female estate subsequent to the Bryson review, what is clear is that the new Ministry of Justice policy would see all seven relocated to men’s prisons.
Scotland now has a new First Minister following his election as SNP party leader. The cabinet has also changed, with Angela Constance appointed as Cabinet Secretary for Justice.
Just as I hope that other departments in Westminster will take inspiration from the Ministry of Justice, I trust that the Scottish Government and Scottish Prison Service will also look to the measures this policy puts in place and see them as the minimum standard for protecting women in prison.
I suspect, however, that Scottish Tory MSPs will need to keep up the pressure.