Jacques Arnold was MP for Gravesham from 1987 until 1997.
I have been a Member of the Conservative Party for 54 years, as a doorstep campaigner, and also as a branch and Association Chairman and President, also elected as a county councillor and Member of Parliament. During that time, particularly in this century, I have seen the systematic destruction of the party at grassroots campaigning level, by the leeching to the centre of resources and imposition of damaging bureaucratic regulations.
The great strength of the Conservative Party (and the historic Liberal Party) was its development upwards from the constituencies, in contrast to the top-down development of the Labour Party. The constituency associations were a sovereign power base. Conservative Central Office was developed as such, reporting to the parliamentary leader, to facilitate coordination and provide common services as required by the National Union (of Conservative Associations).
This served us well. Central Office added the task of running a parliamentary candidates’ list. Originally strongly influenced by social criteria, the shock of the result of the disastrous 1945 election resulted in a meritocratic criteria that brought forward the giants – Ian Macleod, Reginald Maudling, Enoch Powell, Ted Heath and Margaret Thatcher. Central Office subsisted on direct business and personal contributions, but also on voluntary contributions by wealthy Associations, which competed in an annually published list of such donations.
All changed with Tony Blair’s imposition of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. The preparation of the then Bill involved Agents of all three parties. The long-standing envy by Central Office concerning the funds of the Associations, and the protective secrecy they maintained, resulted in their collusion to establish registered political parties, with the sovereign Associations reduced to mere “accounting units”, thus revealing publicly their funds.
Central Office had suffered a drought of contributions during the latter John Major years, which resulted in prospective bankruptcy post the 1997 election, leading to the sacking of many experienced senior agents. The survivors were determined to safeguard their situation, even at the expense of the party in the field.
Following enactment, which was a deplorable act of centralisation, Central Office re-labelled itself Conservative Campaign Headquarters, and abandoned the historic term Agent, replacing it with “Campaign Directors”, who proceeded to interfere with the activities of the Associations, attempting to direct local volunteers, with inevitable consequences. They also imposed new constitutions on the Associations, which may have complied with the Act, but also introduced much bureaucracy and rights of CCHQ to interfere.
To add to the impositions on local Associations, they introduced a centralised membership list, taking to themselves the sole right to enrol Members, and charged £10 per member for that privilege (subsequently increasing that charge by 50 per cent to £15. Their original pledge not to use the membership lists for central fund raising was rapidly discarded, and members were increasingly bombarded by central fund-raising projects, further depleting local Association funds.
The deprivation of £15 of the £25 membership fee, has resulted in the loss of constituency agents, and weakening of local funds for “In Touch” leaflets and local election campaigns. The result exacerbated the recent severe local government election losses.
Demonstrating how out of touch they have become, they have now imposed £39 membership fees (a 44 per cent increase) immediately on new members, and from January 1 on existing members, regardless of local opinion, or the current financial strain on supporters’ funds. The impact on party membership numbers will be dire.
To further add to our woes, CCHQ abandoned the priority of meritocracy in parliamentary recruitment, in favour of the politically correct chasing of unofficial quotas of women (Women2Win), ethnic minorities and other fashionable criteria. The reverse of that coin was the turning-away of high quality middle-class male applicants.
When one considers the calibre and quality of previous women Members, like Nancy Astor, Margaret Thatcher, Betty Harvie Anderson, Irene Ward, Peggy Fenner, Ann Widdecombe or even Edwina Currie, any suggestion they needed special priority is insulting. Likewise with Rishi Sunak, Sajid Javid, Nadhim Zahawi, Kwasi Kwarteng, Priti Patel or Suella Braverman. All of them were either selected under the old meritocratic policies, or would have been. Instead, they have been patronised. This partly explains the decline in quality in the parliamentary party, and raises the question: where are the political giants today?
The new stock Association constitutions have also affected local council candidate selection. The emphasis on campaigning performance and mutual aid records, at the expense of local ward service and reputation, has resulted in the deselection of longstanding councillors, leading to ward election losses and even party control of councils.
Taken together, all these developments have resulted in the evaporation and implosion of the voluntary party in the field. The knock-on effect is typical of the centralisation and leeching suffered by other nationwide organisations such as the the Church of England. The “father knows best” approach is doing immense damage to the Party in the field. It will knock onwards to our performance at the next general election. Is it too late to appreciate our local voluntary activists, and also to select nationally on the basis of merit?
Jacques Arnold was MP for Gravesham from 1987 until 1997.
I have been a Member of the Conservative Party for 54 years, as a doorstep campaigner, and also as a branch and Association Chairman and President, also elected as a county councillor and Member of Parliament. During that time, particularly in this century, I have seen the systematic destruction of the party at grassroots campaigning level, by the leeching to the centre of resources and imposition of damaging bureaucratic regulations.
The great strength of the Conservative Party (and the historic Liberal Party) was its development upwards from the constituencies, in contrast to the top-down development of the Labour Party. The constituency associations were a sovereign power base. Conservative Central Office was developed as such, reporting to the parliamentary leader, to facilitate coordination and provide common services as required by the National Union (of Conservative Associations).
This served us well. Central Office added the task of running a parliamentary candidates’ list. Originally strongly influenced by social criteria, the shock of the result of the disastrous 1945 election resulted in a meritocratic criteria that brought forward the giants – Ian Macleod, Reginald Maudling, Enoch Powell, Ted Heath and Margaret Thatcher. Central Office subsisted on direct business and personal contributions, but also on voluntary contributions by wealthy Associations, which competed in an annually published list of such donations.
All changed with Tony Blair’s imposition of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. The preparation of the then Bill involved Agents of all three parties. The long-standing envy by Central Office concerning the funds of the Associations, and the protective secrecy they maintained, resulted in their collusion to establish registered political parties, with the sovereign Associations reduced to mere “accounting units”, thus revealing publicly their funds.
Central Office had suffered a drought of contributions during the latter John Major years, which resulted in prospective bankruptcy post the 1997 election, leading to the sacking of many experienced senior agents. The survivors were determined to safeguard their situation, even at the expense of the party in the field.
Following enactment, which was a deplorable act of centralisation, Central Office re-labelled itself Conservative Campaign Headquarters, and abandoned the historic term Agent, replacing it with “Campaign Directors”, who proceeded to interfere with the activities of the Associations, attempting to direct local volunteers, with inevitable consequences. They also imposed new constitutions on the Associations, which may have complied with the Act, but also introduced much bureaucracy and rights of CCHQ to interfere.
To add to the impositions on local Associations, they introduced a centralised membership list, taking to themselves the sole right to enrol Members, and charged £10 per member for that privilege (subsequently increasing that charge by 50 per cent to £15. Their original pledge not to use the membership lists for central fund raising was rapidly discarded, and members were increasingly bombarded by central fund-raising projects, further depleting local Association funds.
The deprivation of £15 of the £25 membership fee, has resulted in the loss of constituency agents, and weakening of local funds for “In Touch” leaflets and local election campaigns. The result exacerbated the recent severe local government election losses.
Demonstrating how out of touch they have become, they have now imposed £39 membership fees (a 44 per cent increase) immediately on new members, and from January 1 on existing members, regardless of local opinion, or the current financial strain on supporters’ funds. The impact on party membership numbers will be dire.
To further add to our woes, CCHQ abandoned the priority of meritocracy in parliamentary recruitment, in favour of the politically correct chasing of unofficial quotas of women (Women2Win), ethnic minorities and other fashionable criteria. The reverse of that coin was the turning-away of high quality middle-class male applicants.
When one considers the calibre and quality of previous women Members, like Nancy Astor, Margaret Thatcher, Betty Harvie Anderson, Irene Ward, Peggy Fenner, Ann Widdecombe or even Edwina Currie, any suggestion they needed special priority is insulting. Likewise with Rishi Sunak, Sajid Javid, Nadhim Zahawi, Kwasi Kwarteng, Priti Patel or Suella Braverman. All of them were either selected under the old meritocratic policies, or would have been. Instead, they have been patronised. This partly explains the decline in quality in the parliamentary party, and raises the question: where are the political giants today?
The new stock Association constitutions have also affected local council candidate selection. The emphasis on campaigning performance and mutual aid records, at the expense of local ward service and reputation, has resulted in the deselection of longstanding councillors, leading to ward election losses and even party control of councils.
Taken together, all these developments have resulted in the evaporation and implosion of the voluntary party in the field. The knock-on effect is typical of the centralisation and leeching suffered by other nationwide organisations such as the the Church of England. The “father knows best” approach is doing immense damage to the Party in the field. It will knock onwards to our performance at the next general election. Is it too late to appreciate our local voluntary activists, and also to select nationally on the basis of merit?