“Armageddon is upon us,” Allister Heath announces in The Daily Telegraph, while Fraser Nelson contends in The Spectator that Nigel Farage and his followers may “enable a mass suicide of the Right”.
Gloomy prognostications that the Conservative Party is about to be smashed have tended to obscure the advances made by small-c conservatism within the Labour Party.
Sir Keir Starmer has put his party on course for victory by forcing it to adopt a small-c conservative programme. He was elected Labour leader in 2020 by making Ten Pledges which reassured its members that he was, essentially, a man of the Left.
Among many other proposals, he promised to increase income tax for the top five per cent of earners, scrap tuition fees, defend free movement as Britain left the EU, abolish Universal Credit and abolish the House of Lords.
These pledges have been abandoned, along with much else from the period when Jeremy Corbyn led the party and Starmer praised him.
Interviewers have naturally sought, in this campaign, to embarrass Starmer by reminding him of his endorsements for his predecessor.
But like every successful Labour leader before him, Starmer understands the need to reassure voters in Middle England that he is not a dangerous ideologue, allied to other dangerous ideologues, but a sober, prudent, conventional leader, with sober, prudent, conventional plans for the public finances, and for other matters too.
None of this means Starmer will be a successful Prime Minister, but it does make him a successful candidate, for whom Middle England reckons it can vote in order to attain a change of government without any violent change of policy.
Daniel Finkelstein this week wrote in The Times that “on almost every political dispute over our entire adult lives”, i.e. for the past 40 years, “Starmer has taken a position to the left of me”, but has then often shifted his position rightwards.
Finkelstein considers the various disreputable explanations there could be for this, before concluding:
“Starmer has not lied about his politics. He is someone with a left-wing instinct; he’s not Tony Blair, he’s not even Gordon Brown. But he is also a pragmatist and deeply realistic. And this leads him again and again to temper his initial view.
“Starmer is bright and extremely diligent and often finds that evidence and reality push him away from his ideological starting point. As Director of Public Prosecutions he couldn’t maintain the purist stance of the human rights lawyer acting for the defence. The advocate for activists complaining about police abuse came to appreciate the difficulties of policing. The defendant’s friend became acquainted with the experiences of victims.”
This surely is correct. Starmer is a pragmatist. When there is a conflict between what works in practice and what is right in theory, he will advocate the former, once he has managed to identify it.
Conquest’s First Law, “Generally speaking, everybody is reactionary on subjects he knows about,” applies to Starmer.
So the Left already feels betrayed by him. It expresses strong support for Corbyn, expelled from the Labour Party, and volunteers have flocked to support his campaign as an Independent in Islington North.
In Starmer’s own seat, Holborn and St Pancras, an Independent, Andrew Feinstein, is standing against him on a Corbynite ticket, has no prospect of victory, but has mobilised a considerable number of volunteers.
Starmer’s left-leaning local paper, The Camden New Journal, writes this week of “the unholy alliance between Labour and the Conservatives”, says “most people on the Left will hold their nose to get the Tories out”, but adds that “the real fight begins on 5th July”, when left-wing activists and “unions calling workers out on strike” will have to keep up “the pressure to renationalise the railways, NHS and utilities companies”.
Starmer will doubtless try to use these protests by the Left to continue demonstrating to Middle England that he is an essentially sound person.
But it is one thing to learn from the Conservatives while in Opposition, quite another to do so once in Downing Street, for the failures which are blamed on the present Government will quickly become Starmer’s failures.
He himself may not yet have decided whether, under pressure of events, he is going to borrow yet more extensively from his predecessors in office. As Bagehot observed in his essay on The Character of Sir Robert Peel,
“The calling of a constitutional statesman is very much that of a political advocate; he receives a new brief with the changing circumstances of each successive day.”
Like Blair before him, Starmer cannot resist dressing up whatever he is doing in the highest moral terms. But if he sees a practical case for stealing the Opposition’s clothes, by adopting the Rwanda plan which until now he has so steadfastly opposed, he would not, one guesses, find it beyond his powers of advocacy to justify such a startling volte-face.