James Cowling is the Managing Director of Next Gen Tories, a campaign group calling for the Conservatives to focus on winning back the support of working-age voters.
After the devastating rout at the election, it doesn’t take a political genius to highlight that the Conservative Party needs to rebuild bridges with vast swathes of the electorate.
Renewing the party’s offering is essential for any chance of being back in power in the next decade. Aside from ending the infighting and instability, the next leader must address the single biggest factor leading to this historic defeat: working-age people no longer vote Conservative.
The Conservatives are now almost entirely reliant on the pensioner vote, and Labour was significantly ahead with every working-age demographic. The party polls around fourth or fifth with the under-25s whilst the generation hitting their thirties and forties isn’t getting more conservative as they age, as every previous generation did.
If we extrapolate this trend, by the next election one in six Tory voters may have died.
To put it in more human terms, as an activist out canvassing, if someone under forty-five answers the door my gut immediately assumes they won’t be voting Conservative. The hunch is usually right. The scale of the gap means the party is not even picking up the fertile territory of millennials, who naturally have a centre-right outlook.
The wastage of working-age support means the party has atrophied at a local level. This has had real-world implications, as seats that were historically safe suddenly found they had almost no activists young enough to do the physically demanding job of knocking on doors and delivering leaflets. One area I went to hadn’t been properly canvassed in twenty years.
I founded the campaign group Next Gen Tories to urge the party to refocus on delivering for working-age people.
There are several key areas where we need a more coherent plan: housing, family, and the burden of taxes on work. The basic arguments of aspiration – that you should be able to achieve success and create wealth regardless of your start in life, and that the Conservatives stand for homeownership and family – have gradually become unfamiliar to the party.
The general election was unfortunately a caricature of the strategy Next Gen Tories cautioned against. The ‘triple lock plus’ and national service were deliberate bungs to the pensioner vote, but there was little for any other demographic.
We allowed Labour to be seen as the party of homeownership, and the Conservatives of low-growth NIMBYism. There was no sincere effort to speak to the concerns of working-age people, and too few policies to fix them.
I may sound alarmist by painting this picture, but I am in fact quite optimistic about the future the party could have if it chooses to. If we show contrition and a willingness to come to grips with the challenge, the Conservatives could be match fit ahead of the next election.
But it will require our next leader to be brave enough to change course from the status quo, and undoubtedly take some flak as a minority of resistant MPs and councillors hanker for the comfort of slow decline. A clean break with the past is an absolute necessity if our next leader hopes to ever become Prime Minister.
Housebuilding is one of the clearest examples of where the party fell short and there is an opportunity to do better. After positioning themselves as the alternative to Conservative inertia, the Government’s proposals have fallen way short of expectations.
Targets for building in cities have been slashed, despite these being the areas where densification is most heavily needed. London has seen its targets slashed by 20 per cent, hardly a bold approach. Conversely, building pressures have been pushed onto some truly odd areas, including a big uptick in the Lake District. There has been no sign significant supply-side reforms, despite the post-election period being the critical moment to introduce such measures.
As a result, the housing crisis will be worse by the next election than it is today. Working-age people will continue to be priced out of homeownership, and increasingly frustrated as their aspirations to get on in life are delayed once again.
There are two ways in which our next leader can respond. The first would be to adopt an approach of blanket opposition to building and development, making Conservatives look unserious about one of the biggest challenges facing the UK. It goes without saying that this is not a winning strategy.
The second option is to have a thoughtful conversation about how to meet the UK’s housing needs without overdeveloping green spaces. There are a myriad of policies that promote gentle density in suburban areas and greater density in urban areas. Meaningful supply-side reform to increase building rates is a non-negotiable.
But this doesn’t make it incompatible with building more beautiful and better-located homes. International examples, such as those adopted in some US states and New Zealand, show that urban redevelopment can be delivered well. Adopting a stance along these lines typifies the approach that will lead us back into power, and that will win back working-age people.
This is not a question of pitting the old against the young. The success of working-age people determines their ability to support an ageing population, and older people are increasingly concerned that their children and grandchildren are worse off than they were at the same age.
Policies that appeal to older voters can be paired with those that appeal to the young; for example, lowering immigration whilst building more high-quality houses is a perfectly complementary policy offering that would be widely popular.
A platform that wins back the working-age vote is entirely achievable – the revival of the Canadian Tories shows that (and how) it can be done. Capitalist, centre-right answers can reignite aspirational conservativism; my plea to Conservative MPs and our next leader is to use this period of opposition wisely, and carve out a road to recovery.
James Cowling is the Managing Director of Next Gen Tories, a campaign group calling for the Conservatives to focus on winning back the support of working-age voters.
After the devastating rout at the election, it doesn’t take a political genius to highlight that the Conservative Party needs to rebuild bridges with vast swathes of the electorate.
Renewing the party’s offering is essential for any chance of being back in power in the next decade. Aside from ending the infighting and instability, the next leader must address the single biggest factor leading to this historic defeat: working-age people no longer vote Conservative.
The Conservatives are now almost entirely reliant on the pensioner vote, and Labour was significantly ahead with every working-age demographic. The party polls around fourth or fifth with the under-25s whilst the generation hitting their thirties and forties isn’t getting more conservative as they age, as every previous generation did.
If we extrapolate this trend, by the next election one in six Tory voters may have died.
To put it in more human terms, as an activist out canvassing, if someone under forty-five answers the door my gut immediately assumes they won’t be voting Conservative. The hunch is usually right. The scale of the gap means the party is not even picking up the fertile territory of millennials, who naturally have a centre-right outlook.
The wastage of working-age support means the party has atrophied at a local level. This has had real-world implications, as seats that were historically safe suddenly found they had almost no activists young enough to do the physically demanding job of knocking on doors and delivering leaflets. One area I went to hadn’t been properly canvassed in twenty years.
I founded the campaign group Next Gen Tories to urge the party to refocus on delivering for working-age people.
There are several key areas where we need a more coherent plan: housing, family, and the burden of taxes on work. The basic arguments of aspiration – that you should be able to achieve success and create wealth regardless of your start in life, and that the Conservatives stand for homeownership and family – have gradually become unfamiliar to the party.
The general election was unfortunately a caricature of the strategy Next Gen Tories cautioned against. The ‘triple lock plus’ and national service were deliberate bungs to the pensioner vote, but there was little for any other demographic.
We allowed Labour to be seen as the party of homeownership, and the Conservatives of low-growth NIMBYism. There was no sincere effort to speak to the concerns of working-age people, and too few policies to fix them.
I may sound alarmist by painting this picture, but I am in fact quite optimistic about the future the party could have if it chooses to. If we show contrition and a willingness to come to grips with the challenge, the Conservatives could be match fit ahead of the next election.
But it will require our next leader to be brave enough to change course from the status quo, and undoubtedly take some flak as a minority of resistant MPs and councillors hanker for the comfort of slow decline. A clean break with the past is an absolute necessity if our next leader hopes to ever become Prime Minister.
Housebuilding is one of the clearest examples of where the party fell short and there is an opportunity to do better. After positioning themselves as the alternative to Conservative inertia, the Government’s proposals have fallen way short of expectations.
Targets for building in cities have been slashed, despite these being the areas where densification is most heavily needed. London has seen its targets slashed by 20 per cent, hardly a bold approach. Conversely, building pressures have been pushed onto some truly odd areas, including a big uptick in the Lake District. There has been no sign significant supply-side reforms, despite the post-election period being the critical moment to introduce such measures.
As a result, the housing crisis will be worse by the next election than it is today. Working-age people will continue to be priced out of homeownership, and increasingly frustrated as their aspirations to get on in life are delayed once again.
There are two ways in which our next leader can respond. The first would be to adopt an approach of blanket opposition to building and development, making Conservatives look unserious about one of the biggest challenges facing the UK. It goes without saying that this is not a winning strategy.
The second option is to have a thoughtful conversation about how to meet the UK’s housing needs without overdeveloping green spaces. There are a myriad of policies that promote gentle density in suburban areas and greater density in urban areas. Meaningful supply-side reform to increase building rates is a non-negotiable.
But this doesn’t make it incompatible with building more beautiful and better-located homes. International examples, such as those adopted in some US states and New Zealand, show that urban redevelopment can be delivered well. Adopting a stance along these lines typifies the approach that will lead us back into power, and that will win back working-age people.
This is not a question of pitting the old against the young. The success of working-age people determines their ability to support an ageing population, and older people are increasingly concerned that their children and grandchildren are worse off than they were at the same age.
Policies that appeal to older voters can be paired with those that appeal to the young; for example, lowering immigration whilst building more high-quality houses is a perfectly complementary policy offering that would be widely popular.
A platform that wins back the working-age vote is entirely achievable – the revival of the Canadian Tories shows that (and how) it can be done. Capitalist, centre-right answers can reignite aspirational conservativism; my plea to Conservative MPs and our next leader is to use this period of opposition wisely, and carve out a road to recovery.