The Prime Minister wags his finger! He wags a finger from each hand! His dignity, his very probity, are being called into question, and this he cannot tolerate.
But he will have to tolerate it. Kemi Badenoch pointed out to Sir Keir Starmer that he “played politics with the WASPI women,” and this hurt him, for he could find no way to show that he had not played politics with the WASPI women.
How gloomy the non-WASPI women sitting on either side of him, Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves, were looking. For them too this is a painful subject, on which the line taken by Labour in Opposition turns out to be incompatible with the line taken by Labour in Government.
The Prime Minister kept being stung by the WASPI women. When Ben Lake (Plaid Cymru, Ceredigion Preseli) raised their cause, Starmer attempted the statesmanlike regret with which he had refused to gratify the infuriating Badenoch.
“It is a serious issue,” he said. “It’s a complex issue. And I’m afraid to say the taxpayer simply can’t afford the tens of billions of pounds in compensation.”
But here, a moment or two later, was one of his own backbenchers, Ian Byrne (Liverpool West Derby) reporting that in his own constituency more than 5,000 women are affected, declaring that like “a great many Members in this House I believe these women are owed compensation”, and asking the Prime Minister for a vote on the matter.
“I’ve just set out the factual background,” the PM replied, and repeated the line that “the taxpayer can’t bear the burden of tens of billions of pounds in compensation.”
This is the correct line for the Government to take. The problem is that it was not taken while the party was in Opposition.
The Speaker, Sir Lindsay Hoyle, called the Mother of the House, Diane Abbott (Lab, Hackney North and Stoke Newington), who was heard in silence as she said: “I understand the issue about the cost but does the Prime Minister really understand how let down the WASPI women feel today?”
“I do understand the concern, of course I do,” Starmer replied. He cannot emote, and has not yet worked out how to make a virtue of standing up for the taxpayer.
Perhaps he will in time discover how to do this. His instinct when faced by a difficulty is to put his head down and work his way through it.
It is just possible that in four years’ time he and Reeves will be able to declare that they upheld the interests of taxpayers.
But that was not how it felt today. The faith of his backbenchers in the Prime Minister has been shaken, and he could not find the words needed to restore it.
“Never glad confident morning again!” was the line of verse which leapt to mind.