Sir Keir Starmer was pale, indignant, at times deeply emotional. The House watched him strain every sinew as he defended his good name.
Often he was heard in silence, for the gang rape of young girls is not a subject which lends itself to heckling. The Prime Minister wished to prove that he and his colleagues are the righteous ones, with a perfect right to the moral high ground, while Kemi Badenoch and her followers are a bunch of Twitter-obsessed hypocrites who only became interested in the scandal in the last few days and did nothing about it during their 14 years in government.
At the start of PMQs the Prime Minister was given the chance by one of his backbenchers, Neil Coyle (Bermondsey and Old Southwark), to set out the Government’s defence.
One part of that defence is designed to appeal to any fair-minded person: “Reasonable people can agree or disagree on whether a further inquiry is necessary,” the Prime Minister declared.
The other part of his defence, impossible to reconcile with this display of sweet reason, is that anyone who disagrees with the Government’s approach, or presumes to question his past record, is by definition a bad person who deserves to be cast into outer darkness.
“What I find shocking,” the PM said, his voice becoming emotional, “is that anyone in this House would vote down the Children’s Wellbeing Bill.”
But as that great hooligan Lord Randolph Churchill once said, “The duty of an Opposition is to oppose.” Kemi Badenoch and her colleagues are there to make the Government’s life difficult, not to wave its measures through.
And this Starmer finds impossible to accept. He does not feel such parliamentary tactics are legitimate, and yearns to show that anyone who stands in his way is bad.
He accused Kemi Badenoch of never raising the scandal in the House when she was a government minister, and contrasted this with his own admirable record as Director of Public Prosecutions: “When I was Chief Prosecutor I took measures to confront this head on.”
Badenoch retorted that “this is not about you”, and accused him of opposing a new inquiry because “he doesn’t want questions asked of Labour politicians who may be complicit”.
A high degree of disingenuousness was displayed by both contestants as they traded high sentiments and low blows. Neither side knocked the other out, but we saw how much Starmer’s idea of himself as a virtuous person matters to him, and how intolerable he finds any attack on his good name.
Under pressure, the knight in shining armour becomes resentful. He cannot bear being held up to public view as a bad person, and indicates by his demeanour that attacks on his integrity should not be allowed. Badenoch now has the chance to torment him.