The vulnerability of Sir Keir Starmer becomes week by week more evident. He speaks the language of an apparatchik, clunky, huffy, resentful of criticism, suspicious of freedom, inclined to confuse the announcement of the five-year plan with its implementation.
“We’re driving standards up,” he told Kemi Badenoch when she questioned the effect the Education Bill will have on standards.
Badenoch stuck to education for all six questions. She did not please journalists by doing so, for education is not at the top of the news list, and her approach was not productive of a story.
But she was right to do this, because she started to show the difference between the Conservative approach to education, which includes giving freedom to head teachers to hire talented people from other fields and pay good teachers more, and Starmer’s approach, which as she said is to hand power over to the teaching unions.
Starmer later insisted that the Government is “driving up growth”, and said that “at the heart of our Plan for Change is growth”.
If it’s in the Plan for Change it must, he implied, be happening. But change and growth are more spontaneous than is dreamt of in this apparatchik’s philosophy, and tend to occur when the Government gets out of the way.
Sir Bernard Jenkin (Con, Harwich and North Essex) remarked that the recent Budget “raised taxes, raised borrowing and raised public spending as a strategy for economic growth”, and wondered when Starmer was going to accept the words of a Labour Prime Minister in the 1970s “who explained to a Labour Conference that in all candour that option no longer exists”?
Starmer declined to take up the reference to James Callaghan, but instead rattled off a catalogue of encouraging economic statistics, including the IMF’s growth forecast, which he presumably had to hand in case Badenoch asked about the economy.
Recitation of encouraging statistics is a favoured way for apparatchiks to persuade themselves that all is well. They prefer it to getting out of the office and talking to people.
Sir Ed Davey, for the Liberal Democrats, asked how Baroness Casey, who chairs the Social Care Commission, will also find time to chair the inquiry into grooming gangs.
Starmer explained how this brilliant apparatchik will be able to carry out both pieces of work: “Baroness Casey is well placed to conduct the audit into grooming gangs given her hard-hitting report on exploitation in Rotherham. It does not affect her work on the Social Care Commission which begins in April.”
Hard-hitting reports are another device beloved of the apparatchik, offering as they do the appearance of action. We must hope and pray that the Prime Minister takes the precautions needed to avert a nasty accident when a great pile of hard-hitting reports by Baroness Casey topples over and hits him at his desk just as he is putting the finishing touches to a new edition of the Plan for Change.