Sir Keir Starmer ducked two opportunities to declare his confidence in the Attorney General, Lord Hermer. The first was offered by Kemi Badenoch, who described Hermer as “the Prime Minister’s personal friend and donor”, and quoted the Labour peer Lord Glasman’s description of the Attorney General as “the absolute archetype of an arrogant progressive fool”.
Starmer responded, not by leaping to the defence of his friend and colleague, but by accusing Badenoch of having “sat round the Cabinet table with an Attorney who was later sacked for breaching national security” – a point which has nothing whatever to do with Hermer’s merits or demerits, but seemed designed to suggest that Badenoch has no right to pose questions about him.
Saqib Bhatti (Con, Meriden and Solihull East) asked whether the PM’s “best friend” Hermer represents good value for the British taxpayer, given the advice the Attorney General has given on the Chagos Islands, which will cost the taxpayer up to £18 billion pounds, and on various other matters.
The PM again ducked the chance to say that Hermer is a wonderful Attorney General, instead delivering a short but prosy lecture on the right of everyone to legal representation, and asking whether the Conservatives now disagree with that principle. Once again, he sought to imply that the Opposition has no moral right to challenge him.
Lord Glasman’s disobliging comments about Hermer were published by the New Statesman on Monday, and were bound to come up at PMQs, so No 10 has had plenty of time to consider how the PM should respond.
It appears to have decided his hands must not be tied by a declaration of confidence in Hermer, whom he does indeed know extremely well.
Starmer’s answers are carefully prepared. His minders do not want him to encumber himself with pro-Hermer words which will be quoted back at him when, as now seems likely, Hermer is sacked.
The Prime Minister has gone along with his minders’ advice. He will not stand and fight for a man he only appointed in July. He is getting ready to lay down his friend for his life.