Dr Robert Seely MBE is author of ‘The New Total War’, ConservativeHome foreign affairs columnist and a former Conservative MP.
It will be better for Britain if Labour MP Al Cairns becomes the next Secretary of State for Defence.
I’m clearly not trying to influence the result in any way, and it would probably be mildly unhelpful for Carns in such a tribal party as Labour to have any Tory supporters. The reason I like Carns for the role is because he’s one of the few people in the political world who is thinking about the changing nature of conflict, and to have done so from both a soldier’s point of view but also now an MP and ex-, and potentially future, MoD minister.
I knew Carns a little bit when I was in the military, but not to any great extent and I don’t claim any great knowledge of him.
Carns was very much a soldier’s soldier.
He didn’t necessarily come across as a ‘cerebral’ officer, but looks can deceive. He’s done valuable staff officer roles and his command, leading the SAS’s sister unit the Special Boat Service, demanded a unique skill set, including the ability to solve complex problems under intense pressure. He wouldn’t have got the job if he didn’t have stand-out intellectual and physical qualities.
One shouldn’t underestimate his political nous too. For a start, Special Forces work is about small teams delivering strategic effect. It’s inherently political and led by people who see the bigger picture. In Parliament, he’s also been one of the few of the Labour Parliamentary intake who has stood out.
To advertise his credentials, Carns has been regularly posting ideas on twitter/X as part of his campaign to get the defence role, in between some impressive pull-up/chin-up exercise videos.
Last weekend he wrote about critical national technologies (CNT), home defence and national resilience. It veered to make some general points about his view of society, but what he had to say about national technologies, Artificial Intelligence (AI) and resilience was useful.
So he’s argued, for example, that whilst we treat power stations pipelines and telecoms as CNT, we don’t do the same for nuclear and advanced manufacturing. Neither do we with AI, semiconductors, data and quantum science. By contrast, Germany, France, America and China all have ambitions in our AI and industrial strategy and sovereign capability.
“Data is the new gunpowder,” he says.
It’s certainly an important part of the equation. And Carns would have read the reports coming out of Ukraine showing how AI-driven software is turbo-charging speed of decision-making in the conflict. Two platforms in particular, DELTA and Arta, have revolutionised the battlefield for Ukrainians, reducing the targeting cycle – that’s the time it takes to find a target to launch against it – from one hour to one minute. This is one reason why Ukraine is now beginning to win.
Carns knows we need more of that here, developed not slowly over years, but more quickly from start-up firms. But this is just one element. To the need for a sovereign semiconductor capability, you can add rare earth and raw material supply, much of which has been hoovered up by China on long-term contracts. Yet under both the previous Government and this one, we continue to allow China to asset strip national champions.
So Carns calls for a Critical National Technology Category with “privileges and benefits.” “If we don’t create, scale and support the technologies of the future, we become vulnerable to others that will.”
He’s right.
True, a cynic would say you won’t need privileges if we had a low-tax economy, and Labour are building a high-tax, high-regulation economy which is actively driving entrepreneurs away. One could also say that we were one of three world leaders in AI, but Labour’s self-destructive net-zero strategy is putting pay to that. We are experiencing wasted years.
In defence tech – and I speak as someone involved in this – companies will have to go where they get orders, in part due to the national procurement strategies, but it doesn’t help that the UK is becoming so uncompetitive. Germany will dominate defence tech in Europe because it’s the German government spending the most money and offering the biggest orders. In the UK, we have run down our defence sector because of an ill-placed moral condescension over defence, whilst at the same time having a dysfunctional procurement system which gives military chiefs too much power and not enough responsibility.
The most important part of all this is what he says about resilience.
Put bluntly, the UK is incredibly vulnerable; our social cohesion is weak, and home air defence is non-existent, we have one specialist ship to protect the sub-sea internet and energy cables/pipelines, without which we would be blind. We lack the capacity to produce reliable energy at a reasonable cost. We could be knocked out of the next conflict on the first day with a combination of cyber and physical attacks backed by sophisticated disinformation campaigns designed to spread panic and to set people against each other.
Just this weekend we learned of another major Russian hack of the UK Government. They are not doing this because they are bored, but because they are preparing.
My own PhD was in Russian warfare, and I see and understand how much emphasis not only Russia but also China puts on the non-military forms of conflict, undermining an adversary society using non-conventional forms of conflict. Few in the West understand this; Carns does, certainly more than most.
Carns then makes two broader, political points to pitch himself on the Labour right. Carns ties the rebuilding of technology to a wider pitch about training the next generation of engineers, scientists and service personnel, linking it to national renewal and to a wider point of service and volunteering, “something you did because you were part of something bigger than yourself.” These are attractive ideas. Again, the cynic might look to the Left’s relentless attack on these values, but one should at least be grateful that some in Labour actually believe this – and I have no doubt that Carns does.
In fact, if you didn’t know who was writing the post, it could easily be a Nick Timothy-style Conservative, or a Danny Kruger-style Reform, pitch; service and community, work and moral purpose. Once upon a time, this was commonplace; now it’s getting rare and is all but invisible in Labour. It’s certainly a world away from the average Labour welfare-junky MP. In the debate between localists and globalists – the ‘somewheres’ versus ‘anywheres’ in David Goodhart’s book, The Road to Somewhere, Carns comes across as the opposite of Sir Keir Starmer’s discredited ‘Davos’ man/human rights lawyer.
I accept that one isn’t going to solve the world’s problems on Twitter/X, but right now, having a few MPs who are even thinking about this stuff is a start. On the Tory side, James Cartlidge is engaged, Bernard Jenkin is one of the very few thinking about Russia, and for the Lib Dems former soldier Mike Martin is establishing a Rearmament group in Parliament, launching next week.
There are not enough people in the public debate talking about the next conflict, which we are effectively already in, and how it will evolve.
Carns will not rescue the Labour Party.
He’s far too competent to ever be elected its leader, and saving the Left is beyond any one individual – the shine is coming off Burnham even before he arrives in power. Labour’s collective dinosaur instincts: more tax, more state power, hostility to opinions they can’t control, support for open borders and mass immigration, will doom them.
But having a Defence Secretary at least who will actually lead a debate about the changing character of conflict and the importance of resilience and industrial sovereignty will be valuable for the intellectual development within UK defence as well as part of the wider debate, and right now we are losing our intellectual as well as practical leadership.
It will also mean that an incoming Reform/Conservative coalition, if such a thing happens, will not have to start from scratch. This work, done properly, is far removed from traditional party politics. It just needs to be undertaken by smart people acting in the national interest: old school patriotism, new conflict understanding.
So, Al Carns has a valuable national role to play. We should hope he gets the job and gets this thinking cap on once he has done so. He, along with a small number of engaged people in Parliament, have important work to do.