Greg Smith, is Parliamentary Chairman of Conservative Friends of Israel (Commons) and MP for Mid Buckinghamshire.
On Sunday the United Nations issued another statement on the situation in Gaza urging stronger efforts to facilitate humanitarian aid.
But this time, remarkably, it also directed criticism at Gaza’s “de facto authorities” (the UN’s diplomatic shorthand for Hamas) calling on them to fulfil their responsibilities to facilitate humanitarian operations and protect aid workers.
The UN Deputy Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process Dr. Ramiz Alakbarov was clear about where the threat is coming from: “I strongly condemn the recent obstruction of humanitarian operations in Gaza by the de facto authorities, which endangered humanitarian personnel, intimidated workers delivering lifesaving food assistance and disrupted life-saving humanitarian operations.”
He went on to say, “These incidents are not isolated. They are completely unacceptable and reflect an increasingly dangerous pattern of intimidation, violence and obstruction, including smuggling attempts, targeting and abusing humanitarian operations.”
Even the UN – an institution notoriously riddled with anti-Israel bias – is now acknowledging a truth that is well understood by those have seen what is happening on the ground: the humanitarian crisis in Gaza is not simply about Israel.
So why does the Labour Government still talk as though it is?
Whenever aid deliveries falter, ministers are quick to condemn Israel in language far stronger than they ever use about Hamas. In recent months Keir Starmer has almost exhausted the vocabulary of outrage in condemning Israel over humanitarian access: “unconscionable”, “unspeakable”, “indefensible”, “intolerable”.
When Conservatives have put questions to the Government over Hamas looting aid meant for Gazans, we have been shut down as irritants. Any figures quoted which show an improvement in aid flows via Israel have been dismissed curtly.
Shamefully, the current Labour Foreign Secretary has not visited Israel a single time since she took on her role, while John Healey, who until recently was Defence Secretary did not visit after August 2024, not even to visit the contingent of British troops that participate in the Civil-Military Coordination Centre, the principal multinational mechanism for improving conditions in Gaza. I visited in the early months of its operations and saw for myself the scale of the effort, and the complexity of the challenge, they face.
Ministers take pride in declaring how far UK-Israel relations have deteriorated on their watch, while the information they rely on for their statements to Parliament is generated, and filtered, by interests that overwhelmingly single out Israel for criticism.
Israel undoubtedly has obligations under international humanitarian law, and where it can do more to facilitate aid, it should.
But that is only part of the story.
Hamas started this war. Nearly three years on, it still refuses to disarm. It continues to reject any future for Gaza that does not leave it armed and politically dominant. And as the de facto authority in much of the territory, it continues to shape the security environment in which humanitarian organisations are trying to operate.
That reality cannot simply be wished away.
There have been multiple allegations of Hamas interfering with aid deliveries, intimidating aid workers and exploiting humanitarian supplies for political and military gain. Whether through direct interference, insecurity or the collapse of law and order under its rule, Hamas remains a central part of the humanitarian challenge.
The international community increasingly recognises this.
The Civil-Military Coordination Centre exists precisely because getting aid into Gaza is only the first step. Getting it safely to civilians requires secure routes, coordinated logistics and protection for humanitarian workers operating in one of the world’s most dangerous environments.
If humanitarian access depended only on Israel opening more crossings, there would be no need for an international civil-military coordination mechanism. The CMCC exists because aid distribution is also a security challenge.
Yet Labour’s rhetoric never reflects that reality.
Where is the determination to call out Hamas for refusing to disarm? Where is the recognition that an armed terrorist organisation which rejects peace, clings to power and dominates Gaza is itself a major obstacle to getting aid to those who need it?
Unfortunately, Andy Burnham has already signalled that the anti-Israel rhetoric is likely to increase when he becomes Prime Minister in a few days’ time.
But the people of Gaza deserve honesty, not selective outrage.
Yes, Israel must continue to facilitate humanitarian aid and meet its international obligations.
But Hamas must also be held accountable for perpetuating the conditions that make humanitarian relief so perilous.
Even the United Nations is beginning to say so.
So should Labour.
Greg Smith, is Parliamentary Chairman of Conservative Friends of Israel (Commons) and MP for Mid Buckinghamshire.
On Sunday the United Nations issued another statement on the situation in Gaza urging stronger efforts to facilitate humanitarian aid.
But this time, remarkably, it also directed criticism at Gaza’s “de facto authorities” (the UN’s diplomatic shorthand for Hamas) calling on them to fulfil their responsibilities to facilitate humanitarian operations and protect aid workers.
The UN Deputy Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process Dr. Ramiz Alakbarov was clear about where the threat is coming from: “I strongly condemn the recent obstruction of humanitarian operations in Gaza by the de facto authorities, which endangered humanitarian personnel, intimidated workers delivering lifesaving food assistance and disrupted life-saving humanitarian operations.”
He went on to say, “These incidents are not isolated. They are completely unacceptable and reflect an increasingly dangerous pattern of intimidation, violence and obstruction, including smuggling attempts, targeting and abusing humanitarian operations.”
Even the UN – an institution notoriously riddled with anti-Israel bias – is now acknowledging a truth that is well understood by those have seen what is happening on the ground: the humanitarian crisis in Gaza is not simply about Israel.
So why does the Labour Government still talk as though it is?
Whenever aid deliveries falter, ministers are quick to condemn Israel in language far stronger than they ever use about Hamas. In recent months Keir Starmer has almost exhausted the vocabulary of outrage in condemning Israel over humanitarian access: “unconscionable”, “unspeakable”, “indefensible”, “intolerable”.
When Conservatives have put questions to the Government over Hamas looting aid meant for Gazans, we have been shut down as irritants. Any figures quoted which show an improvement in aid flows via Israel have been dismissed curtly.
Shamefully, the current Labour Foreign Secretary has not visited Israel a single time since she took on her role, while John Healey, who until recently was Defence Secretary did not visit after August 2024, not even to visit the contingent of British troops that participate in the Civil-Military Coordination Centre, the principal multinational mechanism for improving conditions in Gaza. I visited in the early months of its operations and saw for myself the scale of the effort, and the complexity of the challenge, they face.
Ministers take pride in declaring how far UK-Israel relations have deteriorated on their watch, while the information they rely on for their statements to Parliament is generated, and filtered, by interests that overwhelmingly single out Israel for criticism.
Israel undoubtedly has obligations under international humanitarian law, and where it can do more to facilitate aid, it should.
But that is only part of the story.
Hamas started this war. Nearly three years on, it still refuses to disarm. It continues to reject any future for Gaza that does not leave it armed and politically dominant. And as the de facto authority in much of the territory, it continues to shape the security environment in which humanitarian organisations are trying to operate.
That reality cannot simply be wished away.
There have been multiple allegations of Hamas interfering with aid deliveries, intimidating aid workers and exploiting humanitarian supplies for political and military gain. Whether through direct interference, insecurity or the collapse of law and order under its rule, Hamas remains a central part of the humanitarian challenge.
The international community increasingly recognises this.
The Civil-Military Coordination Centre exists precisely because getting aid into Gaza is only the first step. Getting it safely to civilians requires secure routes, coordinated logistics and protection for humanitarian workers operating in one of the world’s most dangerous environments.
If humanitarian access depended only on Israel opening more crossings, there would be no need for an international civil-military coordination mechanism. The CMCC exists because aid distribution is also a security challenge.
Yet Labour’s rhetoric never reflects that reality.
Where is the determination to call out Hamas for refusing to disarm? Where is the recognition that an armed terrorist organisation which rejects peace, clings to power and dominates Gaza is itself a major obstacle to getting aid to those who need it?
Unfortunately, Andy Burnham has already signalled that the anti-Israel rhetoric is likely to increase when he becomes Prime Minister in a few days’ time.
But the people of Gaza deserve honesty, not selective outrage.
Yes, Israel must continue to facilitate humanitarian aid and meet its international obligations.
But Hamas must also be held accountable for perpetuating the conditions that make humanitarian relief so perilous.
Even the United Nations is beginning to say so.
So should Labour.