Brandon To is a political researcher and commentator who has researched for the Conservative Shadow Cabinet. Originally from Hong Kong, he writes primarily on immigration, crime and the economy.
On Remembrance Day, a few minutes before eleven, I was sitting in a McDonald’s with a poppy on my coat. I looked around to see who else was getting ready for the two-minute silence. As far as I could tell, nobody was.
I am not saying that every McDonald’s customer must abandon their Big Mac and fries to observe the silence. They might be observing it quietly. They might be starving. But the contrast stayed with me.
An immigrant with no family connection to Britain’s wartime sacrifices was wearing a poppy, while the country that inherited that history seemed, at least in that moment, less interested.
Last year, I wrote about an elderly couple at Marylebone Station who were delighted to see an Asian immigrant wearing a poppy. I then argued in my column that newcomers must embrace Britain’s traditions. I still believe that. But this year, a harder question has been nagging at me: how can we expect newcomers to embrace Britain’s traditions if Britain itself seems increasingly reluctant to celebrate them?
Part of the reluctance, I suspect, is embarrassment.
Of course, British history is not without its darker chapters. No serious person should pretend otherwise. But there is a difference between examining history critically and becoming so uncomfortable with it that we struggle to celebrate anything at all.
Remembrance is not about pretending Britain has always been right. It is about recognising the sacrifices made by those who served, the lives lost, and showing gratitude to whom we owed our freedoms.
If anything, remembrance should transcend political and cultural divisions. It is one of the few occasions when people from vastly different backgrounds can come together around something greater than themselves.
A poppy does not ask where you were born, what language your parents speak or which religion you follow. It simply invites you to remember.
Think about what Britain actually offers a newcomer to celebrate. Christmas is the obvious one, but it is a Christian festival, and some institutions now handle it with tongs. Recently, a school in Aberdeen reminded parents that, as a “multi-cultural and multi-faith community”, it calls them “winter cards” rather than Christmas cards. Families, it added generously, were still free to call them Christmas cards if they wished. How kind. St George’s Day, strictly speaking, belongs to England rather than Britain. It isn’t even a bank holiday, and some councils apparently treat its flag as a public-order risk.
Diwali, by contrast, lights up Trafalgar Square, and Eid is marked in town halls across the country. Good. I have no objection to any of it. But it leaves a rather odd picture: a country that happily celebrates everyone’s festivals except, slightly embarrassed, its own.
That is exactly why Remembrance and VE Day matter so much. They are not religious. They are not English, Scottish or Welsh. They belong to the whole United Kingdom, and to far more than that. Around 1.5 million Indian soldiers served in the First World War, and 2.5 million in the Second. In December 1941, Hong Kong volunteers fought alongside British, Canadian and Indian troops against the Japanese invasion. For many newcomers, this is not someone else’s history. Their grandparents may be in it.
Last year’s 80th anniversary of VE Day showed the appetite is still there. But if these are the only national days Britain can promote to everyone without a disclaimer, we should work twice as hard on them.
That means schools giving every child, wherever their parents were born, a proper grounding in Britain’s history, constitutional traditions and institutions. It means treating Remembrance and VE Day as pillars of civic education, not letting them pass like any other weekday. And it means public institutions feeling confident celebrating British heritage without assuming that doing so somehow excludes everyone who does not share the same ancestry.
There is nothing inherently hostile about being proud of Britain. A country can welcome different cultures without apologising for having one of its own. In fact, the two should complement each other. Diversity can enrich a society, but it cannot replace the shared foundations that allow people to live together in the first place.
Back in that McDonald’s, eleven o’clock came and went. The queue kept moving. Orders kept being called. Nobody was being exceptionally disrespectful. It simply did not seem to occur to anyone that this was a moment worth stopping for.
To be fair, one McDonald’s is not a national survey. Millions still buy a poppy every November, and the memorials were full. The tradition is not dying. But traditions rarely fade at the Cenotaph. They fade quietly, one generation and one queue at a time.
Britain does not need an immigrant to remind it to wear a poppy. What it needs is the confidence to explain, to newcomers and to its own children, why the country falls silent at eleven.