Max Thompson is Campaigns Officer at the Free Speech Union and a former Conservative advisor.
If there is anything that should unite parliamentarians from across the political divide, it must be the importance of family, and the freedom of parents to have well-meaning and sensitive conversations with their children around the dinner table.
The home should be the place where the hand of the state is felt least — yet all this could change thanks to one sinister piece of legislation: the draft Conversion Practices Bill.
Conversion practices such as the chemical castration of gay men, violent exorcisms, and “corrective rape” are abhorrent. That is why they are already, rightly, illegal.
But this Labour Government, in its infinite wisdom, has done what it so often does: introduced legislation to ban something that is already illegal. In fact, so unnecessary is this legislation that ministers cannot say what practices it would ban that are not already banned. It is a testament to an instinct that Keir Starmer and Andy Burnham share: to tinker around the edges, play performative politics, waste parliamentary time, and curtail a fundamental right.
As Kemi Badenoch, who examined the proposals as Equalities Minister in the last Conservative government, said recently, the Bill is “unworkable” and “a waste of time”, given that existing law already covers abusive practices and protects people from discrimination on the basis of their sexuality.
Unlike other similar bills introduced in the past, this draft legislation does not contain the essential safeguard that protects parents’ ability to have these difficult but important conversations with their children. It increasingly looks as though Labour deliberately — and rather sinisterly — removed this safeguard from the Bill during drafting, and so created the worst possible version of it.
But we must focus on what we do know about this Bill. What it will outlaw is well-intentioned conversation: between parents and their gender-confused children, between therapists and the children in their care, and even between religious leaders and their congregations, when those leaders share their faith’s teachings on sex, gender, and marriage.
A parent who tries to dissuade their child from embarking on life-changing, irreversible, and dangerous medical pathways before the age of eighteen could face up to five years in prison.
And what of the child who transitions, only to realise later that life-changing surgery was not the answer to their problems?
The women’s rights campaigner Helen Joyce has branded the Bill a Trojan horse to smuggle the dangerous agenda of Stonewall and the trans lobby onto the statute book. The Telegraph recently revealed that Stonewall’s head of policy was invited to a meeting at 10 Downing Street to discuss the proposed law, and that Stonewall made recommendations to the MPs and peers scrutinising the Bill. Such unprecedented access to the heart of government for a militant activist group should send shivers down all our spines.
The safety of children and the freedom of parents are being sacrificed on the altar of wokery once more. This Bill is in direct conflict with the recommendations of the 2024 Cass Review into children’s gender identity services, which made clear that cautious, exploratory conversations are exactly what confused young people need. This point was made powerfully by Preet Kaur Gill, the Labour MP, former health minister and former social worker. Preet acknowledged that the Government may be well-intentioned in its aims, but said that the drafting of the Bill risked harming children, and voiced serious concerns about the possibility of parents being prosecuted.
If there is any piece of legislation that should energise a true conservative to take a stand, it is one that seeks to limit parents’ rights and responsibilities. This is that Bill.
The Conversion Practices Bill is currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny in Parliament. A Joint Committee of MPs and peers is hearing evidence from witnesses, and its call for written evidence closes at 5pm on Monday 16 November.
The make-up of this Committee should also alarm us. Olivia Bailey, the former minister who published the Bill in the dying days of the Starmer Government, now sits on the Committee and chairs the Women and Equalities Committee; she is, in effect, marking her own homework. The other member of concern is Alex Barros-Curtis, the Committee’s chair, who before his election to Parliament in 2024 served as Labour’s Executive Director of Legal Affairs and was accused of zealously investigating members and MPs who opposed gender ideology.
In recent weeks, we have seen a number of Labour MPs rightly — and bravely — break ranks with the Government to call for this Bill to be dropped, including Tonia Antoniazzi, Graham Stringer, and Mary Glindon.
More than 1,300 church leaders have also written to Bridget Phillipson, now Minister for Women and Equalities, warning that the Bill will criminalise mainstream Christian parenting and preaching. The signatories, who range from Anglican vicars to Catholic priests, called the poorly drafted Bill “grossly offensive” and warned that it could create a “speech crime” targeting those who teach “mainstream Christian doctrine”.
Teachers have also warned that the proposed ban will expose staff and pupils to prosecution for simply questioning a child’s desire — at any age — to change gender, or for preventing them from using changing rooms allocated to the opposite sex. Thanks to the Bill’s draconian consequences and its broad and vague drafting, teachers and pupils alike will inevitably self-censor.
Parents whose children believed they were of the opposite sex, transitioned, and later questioned or regretted that decision have also expressed their fears.
When Sir Keir Starmer entered Downing Street in July 2024, he promised that Labour would tread more lightly on the lives of the British public. That promise has been broken repeatedly, and this Bill is the most egregious example.
Ministers do not know better than parents, and neither do the activist judges who will be responsible for sending parents to jail for simply caring for their child.
This Bill is a sick and twisted assault on free speech, parental responsibility and religious freedom. It must be stopped.
Max Thompson is Campaigns Officer at the Free Speech Union and a former Conservative advisor.
If there is anything that should unite parliamentarians from across the political divide, it must be the importance of family, and the freedom of parents to have well-meaning and sensitive conversations with their children around the dinner table.
The home should be the place where the hand of the state is felt least — yet all this could change thanks to one sinister piece of legislation: the draft Conversion Practices Bill.
Conversion practices such as the chemical castration of gay men, violent exorcisms, and “corrective rape” are abhorrent. That is why they are already, rightly, illegal.
But this Labour Government, in its infinite wisdom, has done what it so often does: introduced legislation to ban something that is already illegal. In fact, so unnecessary is this legislation that ministers cannot say what practices it would ban that are not already banned. It is a testament to an instinct that Keir Starmer and Andy Burnham share: to tinker around the edges, play performative politics, waste parliamentary time, and curtail a fundamental right.
As Kemi Badenoch, who examined the proposals as Equalities Minister in the last Conservative government, said recently, the Bill is “unworkable” and “a waste of time”, given that existing law already covers abusive practices and protects people from discrimination on the basis of their sexuality.
Unlike other similar bills introduced in the past, this draft legislation does not contain the essential safeguard that protects parents’ ability to have these difficult but important conversations with their children. It increasingly looks as though Labour deliberately — and rather sinisterly — removed this safeguard from the Bill during drafting, and so created the worst possible version of it.
But we must focus on what we do know about this Bill. What it will outlaw is well-intentioned conversation: between parents and their gender-confused children, between therapists and the children in their care, and even between religious leaders and their congregations, when those leaders share their faith’s teachings on sex, gender, and marriage.
A parent who tries to dissuade their child from embarking on life-changing, irreversible, and dangerous medical pathways before the age of eighteen could face up to five years in prison.
And what of the child who transitions, only to realise later that life-changing surgery was not the answer to their problems?
The women’s rights campaigner Helen Joyce has branded the Bill a Trojan horse to smuggle the dangerous agenda of Stonewall and the trans lobby onto the statute book. The Telegraph recently revealed that Stonewall’s head of policy was invited to a meeting at 10 Downing Street to discuss the proposed law, and that Stonewall made recommendations to the MPs and peers scrutinising the Bill. Such unprecedented access to the heart of government for a militant activist group should send shivers down all our spines.
The safety of children and the freedom of parents are being sacrificed on the altar of wokery once more. This Bill is in direct conflict with the recommendations of the 2024 Cass Review into children’s gender identity services, which made clear that cautious, exploratory conversations are exactly what confused young people need. This point was made powerfully by Preet Kaur Gill, the Labour MP, former health minister and former social worker. Preet acknowledged that the Government may be well-intentioned in its aims, but said that the drafting of the Bill risked harming children, and voiced serious concerns about the possibility of parents being prosecuted.
If there is any piece of legislation that should energise a true conservative to take a stand, it is one that seeks to limit parents’ rights and responsibilities. This is that Bill.
The Conversion Practices Bill is currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny in Parliament. A Joint Committee of MPs and peers is hearing evidence from witnesses, and its call for written evidence closes at 5pm on Monday 16 November.
The make-up of this Committee should also alarm us. Olivia Bailey, the former minister who published the Bill in the dying days of the Starmer Government, now sits on the Committee and chairs the Women and Equalities Committee; she is, in effect, marking her own homework. The other member of concern is Alex Barros-Curtis, the Committee’s chair, who before his election to Parliament in 2024 served as Labour’s Executive Director of Legal Affairs and was accused of zealously investigating members and MPs who opposed gender ideology.
In recent weeks, we have seen a number of Labour MPs rightly — and bravely — break ranks with the Government to call for this Bill to be dropped, including Tonia Antoniazzi, Graham Stringer, and Mary Glindon.
More than 1,300 church leaders have also written to Bridget Phillipson, now Minister for Women and Equalities, warning that the Bill will criminalise mainstream Christian parenting and preaching. The signatories, who range from Anglican vicars to Catholic priests, called the poorly drafted Bill “grossly offensive” and warned that it could create a “speech crime” targeting those who teach “mainstream Christian doctrine”.
Teachers have also warned that the proposed ban will expose staff and pupils to prosecution for simply questioning a child’s desire — at any age — to change gender, or for preventing them from using changing rooms allocated to the opposite sex. Thanks to the Bill’s draconian consequences and its broad and vague drafting, teachers and pupils alike will inevitably self-censor.
Parents whose children believed they were of the opposite sex, transitioned, and later questioned or regretted that decision have also expressed their fears.
When Sir Keir Starmer entered Downing Street in July 2024, he promised that Labour would tread more lightly on the lives of the British public. That promise has been broken repeatedly, and this Bill is the most egregious example.
Ministers do not know better than parents, and neither do the activist judges who will be responsible for sending parents to jail for simply caring for their child.
This Bill is a sick and twisted assault on free speech, parental responsibility and religious freedom. It must be stopped.