Thomas Turrell is the London Assembly Member for Bexley and Bromley. He is the Conservative Group’s Spokesman on the Environment.
Politics is about choices. Politicians choose a side during their time in office, and then at elections they ask voters to choose a side too. Voters in Lewisham will no doubt then be wondering why, at time of rising rent and housing storage, their Green-led Council and Green Mayor decided to be on the side of an empty office block.
Ironically, this empty office block is called Lewisham House. Perhaps the Greens should rename this trophy of their incompetence to Lewisham Homeless.
I’m a South-East Londoner. Before moving to Bromley, I spent close to a decade living in Greenwich, where Lewisham High Street was basically my nearest major town centre. So, I was naturally excited to hear that the owners of the Lewisham Shopping Centre wanted to regenerate the centre, and by doing so deliver more than 1,700 new homes. The local area began preparing for this £1.5 billion facelift for the town centre, with shops vacating the centre in anticipation. But instead of backing the plans, which will provide hundreds of new homes with discounted rents for key workers and nearly 100 new homes for social housing, the Greens’ first major intervention into Lewisham was to kill it stone-dead.
It took the Mayor of Lewisham no time to film a video for the council’s social media, trying desperately to blame the shopping centre’s owner, LandSec. There was no mention of the fact that the Lewisham Mayor’s office has been pushing for a higher proportion of “affordable” housing on the scheme, which ultimately rendered the project financially unviable. It was yet another ideologically-driven politician meddling in the market, putting barriers up to new homes, putting blockers in the way of making homes affordable.
The truth of the housing crisis is that big Government is getting in the way. We aren’t building enough homes – not because of a lack of land, but because of a control-freak state that piles on the cost to developers, and then wonders why no-one has the cash to build.
The proposal in Lewisham was for 1,700 new homes, with a regenerated shopping centre to boot. 300 affordable-rent properties would have been provided to a community gripped by a housing crisis; now Lewisham gets nothing. The Green Party says it is on the side of renters: those same renters in Lewisham who are forking out on average 70 per cent of their monthly income just to pay the rent and utilities, who can look to the sky and see the empty shell of Lewisham House instead. Their lives will not be improved by the Council taking the courageous decision to help kill the redevelopment of Lewisham Shopping Centre. Council leaders pontificating about the need to build more affordable housing, whilst ensuring that no housing of any kind is built, will not lower anyone’s bills.
Here is the uncomfortable truth: it doesn’t matter if 30 per cent or 50 per cent of a development is affordable homes – if that developer cannot afford to build, then to quote Willy Wonker, “You lose, you get nothing”. 50 per cent of an empty office block, is no affordable housing.
Nothing could be more duplicitous or two-faced than for Green Politicians to look sad at their phones as they record another video for social media, explaining how there will be no new housing in the town centre: they need only look at their reflections to see who is responsible for that tragic fact.
What we need is an honest conversation about the fact that to build any housing, of any type, in a dense community centre is to provide greater benefit to residents during a housing crisis than to build nothing at all for fear of it being the “wrong type” of housing. I fear, however, that the Greens in Lewisham will make life a lot harder for the borough’s residents before that conversation can be had.