John Bald is a former Ofsted inspector. He is Vice-President of the Conservative Education Society.
The Milburn report stands at the junction – or disjunction – of the education system and the world of work.
On one side is a competing throng of educational theorists, still dominated by the “ progressive” Left, which opposes academic work as elitist, and has had its way in Scotland and Wales, with disastrous results. On the other are the economic theorists, neoliberals and Blairites now challenged by the Woke, as well as the more familiar Trotskyists and Corbynites. Their battles are over money, their weapons data, and at the heart of their fight the lawyer’s question, “Cui bono?” Who benefits? Or, like the millions of children and young people caught up in this maelstrom, who does not?
In the 80s and early 90s I was at this interface, a large further and higher education college, which housed the education department’s reading and language development centre. It offered a very wide range of occupational courses – pre-nursing and nursery nursing, business studies, catering, hotel and restaurant services, construction, design and technology – “bridge” courses for people with learning difficulties, and a small number of degree courses, including a successful music school. Hotel and restaurant students easily found vacation work in London, and returned with interesting stories of boil-in-the bag dishes from top London restaurants, and a celebrity chef with political leanings who arrived for a guest appearance at a well-known establishment and sent out for tins of condensed soup with which to make his sauce.
Management was carried out by large numbers of “Deans” “Principal Lecturers” and above, who spent their time in meetings and did no detectable work. Most students found work when they left.
And that is what has changed.
Employing people is the most expensive thing a business can do, and the upfront costs of replacing them with IT are soon recouped. Saffron Walden, a town of around 20,000 people with perhaps double that in surrounding villages, had five banks when I moved there in the 90s, and now has just one, Nationwide. Supermarkets have self-service tills, the police station has closed, and nearby Cambridge is to lose its very popular Marks and Spencer, many of whose products take advantage of low wage costs in Asia. Farther afield, John Lewis has closed its Peterborough branch, which had been virtually gifted to it by the local council. Business schools, for good reasons, teach efficiency, and that means fewer jobs for fewer people. Where Unions control essential services, notably national rail, and London transport, they can resist to the point of blackmail, but they can’t stop the trend.
I rarely agree with either the Pope or Diane Abbott, but they are both right to point to the lack of work, and the fact that the economy is not serving the people.
“Life,” says Milburn in his Foreword, “is a team sport”.
It doesn’t seem like that to indebted young people whose degrees have not paid out on their promised premium, or to school pupils grinding through mountains of tedious, uninspiring work for low-level GCSE passes that do no more than certify failure. Milburn is honest enough to pin the blame for all of this on politicians as a group, and not just on his opponents. But the Guardian is right – for once – to point to his recommendations as “difficult to implement“ and “absurdly ambitious”.
We can at best hope for some small steps in the right direction, beginning with the proposed work-related options at GCSE, and a drastic reduction in National Insurance for young workers.
John Bald is a former Ofsted inspector. He is Vice-President of the Conservative Education Society.
The Milburn report stands at the junction – or disjunction – of the education system and the world of work.
On one side is a competing throng of educational theorists, still dominated by the “ progressive” Left, which opposes academic work as elitist, and has had its way in Scotland and Wales, with disastrous results. On the other are the economic theorists, neoliberals and Blairites now challenged by the Woke, as well as the more familiar Trotskyists and Corbynites. Their battles are over money, their weapons data, and at the heart of their fight the lawyer’s question, “Cui bono?” Who benefits? Or, like the millions of children and young people caught up in this maelstrom, who does not?
In the 80s and early 90s I was at this interface, a large further and higher education college, which housed the education department’s reading and language development centre. It offered a very wide range of occupational courses – pre-nursing and nursery nursing, business studies, catering, hotel and restaurant services, construction, design and technology – “bridge” courses for people with learning difficulties, and a small number of degree courses, including a successful music school. Hotel and restaurant students easily found vacation work in London, and returned with interesting stories of boil-in-the bag dishes from top London restaurants, and a celebrity chef with political leanings who arrived for a guest appearance at a well-known establishment and sent out for tins of condensed soup with which to make his sauce.
Management was carried out by large numbers of “Deans” “Principal Lecturers” and above, who spent their time in meetings and did no detectable work. Most students found work when they left.
And that is what has changed.
Employing people is the most expensive thing a business can do, and the upfront costs of replacing them with IT are soon recouped. Saffron Walden, a town of around 20,000 people with perhaps double that in surrounding villages, had five banks when I moved there in the 90s, and now has just one, Nationwide. Supermarkets have self-service tills, the police station has closed, and nearby Cambridge is to lose its very popular Marks and Spencer, many of whose products take advantage of low wage costs in Asia. Farther afield, John Lewis has closed its Peterborough branch, which had been virtually gifted to it by the local council. Business schools, for good reasons, teach efficiency, and that means fewer jobs for fewer people. Where Unions control essential services, notably national rail, and London transport, they can resist to the point of blackmail, but they can’t stop the trend.
I rarely agree with either the Pope or Diane Abbott, but they are both right to point to the lack of work, and the fact that the economy is not serving the people.
“Life,” says Milburn in his Foreword, “is a team sport”.
It doesn’t seem like that to indebted young people whose degrees have not paid out on their promised premium, or to school pupils grinding through mountains of tedious, uninspiring work for low-level GCSE passes that do no more than certify failure. Milburn is honest enough to pin the blame for all of this on politicians as a group, and not just on his opponents. But the Guardian is right – for once – to point to his recommendations as “difficult to implement“ and “absurdly ambitious”.
We can at best hope for some small steps in the right direction, beginning with the proposed work-related options at GCSE, and a drastic reduction in National Insurance for young workers.