John Glen is the Conservative MP for Salisbury and PPS to the Leader of the Opposition.
The new team at No.10 and No.11 told us they were delivering a ‘do no harm’ Budget – a very low bar. A fortnight on from the Budget and with the benefit of hearing the Chancellor at the Treasury Select Committee, we can see this bar was not cleared.
John Healey’s first fiscal event replicated missteps of the Starmer-Reeves’ era. His actions have further stoked fiscal risk and uncertainty. Doing nothing to rebuild the credibility his predecessor drained during the first two years of this government.
When the market was looking for transparency, it got secrecy; for clarity, it got opacity; and instead of conviction, it got prevarication. Given the Government is on fiscal “thin ice”, to quote Andy Haldane, and with a sky-high debt-to-GDP ratio, this sort of behaviour increases the risk of a bondholder backlash.
Four warning signs are flashing for lawmakers and financial markets.
First, John Healey has deferred the key decisions which should have been in this Budget into the Spending Review (SR) round – which is not supposed to be a fiscal event. His government has pledged to hold only one such event a year, i.e. the annual Autumn Budget. As such, there is growing uncertainty across Whitehall and markets about the timing of this pivotal (SR), which is traditionally a Spring event.
Healey is either confused or he is concealing from lawmakers and investors whether it will be before, after, or alongside the next Budget. This is acutely awkward for a Chancellor who has resigned over a lack of resources and specificity in defence spending. He deferred setting-out how he will meet the target of spending 3 per cent of GDP on defence from his Budget to the SR without a good explanation. He’s made a multi-billion ‘unfunded’ spending commitment without a timetable, nor a plan for delivering it.
Compounding this uncertainty, the primacy of the Treasury on fiscal matters is being diluted on his watch. He told the Committee that the SR process now has three chiefs: the PM at No.10 and Louise Haigh at No.10 North – alongside him at No.11. This “joint” decision making structure does little to instil confidence regarding cogency and coherence of future policy.
Second, Healey added to this uncertainty by declaring at the Committee that he is unpicking the scorecard and time-horizon for the next SR. He said the Treasury “must look beyond the traditional scorecard period” and the SR will be framed by the PM’s nascent ‘10 Year Plan’. He offered little clarity, but it suggests a break with the conventions of previous exercises. We know the PM and his deputy, Lousie Haigh, want to revise the fiscal rules and the latter explicitly proposed changing the measurement of the debt cycle from one to two parliaments, (i.e. 10 years). To revise the parameters of the upcoming SR at this juncture will be interpreted as being less responsible (and ‘moving the goalposts’) which is the wrong message for investors at the wrong time.
Third, Healey is not pledging to bring down the tax burden nor welfare bills in this parliament – the two are of course linked. Equally, he was not willing to say whether the SR would or would not be a tax raising event. Government pledges to reduce the costs of doing business and boost affordability for households do not sit easily with Healey’s failure to commit to reducing the tax and welfare burden.
It is incredible to claim to be focused on reducing costs and then increase taxes, especially when they are born of a failure to restrain the growth of State spending. This government held a ‘zero-based’ review in 2025 scrutinising every aspect of the government’s £1.3 trillion budget, but did not even quantify the savings identified by it. As the Welfare Secretary, Pat McFadden, told us, Labour MPs as “who can we tax in order to pay benefits to others.”
Finally, the flipside of the fiscal predicament is this government’s opaque plans for growth. Rachel Reeves promised a plan for growth, but it never materialised. Healey likewise.
The Budget contained a record 98 measures, yet the Office for Budget Responsibility did not identify a single measure that met the modest 0.1 per cent threshold for having an impact on growth. The Chancellor, remarkably, was relaxed, saying he isn’t “terribly worried about that” because of the government’s devolution gambit. The records of Wales and Scotland offer scant evidence to support his theory. But it does promise more regulations and newly empowered bureaucrats across the country – which is the ‘Labour way’
Andy Burnham and John Healey’s first Budget was a missed opportunity on many fronts, including growth. This government has done little to make a big pitch for overseas investment. Higher taxes will repel investors and dallying with the EU will confuse matters further.
The Budget was so flat that it has stoked rumours of it being the last of this parliament. If they do intend to hold an election between now and next summer, they will be punished by voters and investors who want to see a government that is prepared to take clear and bold choices on welfare, levels of tax, and defence.
John Glen is the Conservative MP for Salisbury and PPS to the Leader of the Opposition.
The new team at No.10 and No.11 told us they were delivering a ‘do no harm’ Budget – a very low bar. A fortnight on from the Budget and with the benefit of hearing the Chancellor at the Treasury Select Committee, we can see this bar was not cleared.
John Healey’s first fiscal event replicated missteps of the Starmer-Reeves’ era. His actions have further stoked fiscal risk and uncertainty. Doing nothing to rebuild the credibility his predecessor drained during the first two years of this government.
When the market was looking for transparency, it got secrecy; for clarity, it got opacity; and instead of conviction, it got prevarication. Given the Government is on fiscal “thin ice”, to quote Andy Haldane, and with a sky-high debt-to-GDP ratio, this sort of behaviour increases the risk of a bondholder backlash.
Four warning signs are flashing for lawmakers and financial markets.
First, John Healey has deferred the key decisions which should have been in this Budget into the Spending Review (SR) round – which is not supposed to be a fiscal event. His government has pledged to hold only one such event a year, i.e. the annual Autumn Budget. As such, there is growing uncertainty across Whitehall and markets about the timing of this pivotal (SR), which is traditionally a Spring event.
Healey is either confused or he is concealing from lawmakers and investors whether it will be before, after, or alongside the next Budget. This is acutely awkward for a Chancellor who has resigned over a lack of resources and specificity in defence spending. He deferred setting-out how he will meet the target of spending 3 per cent of GDP on defence from his Budget to the SR without a good explanation. He’s made a multi-billion ‘unfunded’ spending commitment without a timetable, nor a plan for delivering it.
Compounding this uncertainty, the primacy of the Treasury on fiscal matters is being diluted on his watch. He told the Committee that the SR process now has three chiefs: the PM at No.10 and Louise Haigh at No.10 North – alongside him at No.11. This “joint” decision making structure does little to instil confidence regarding cogency and coherence of future policy.
Second, Healey added to this uncertainty by declaring at the Committee that he is unpicking the scorecard and time-horizon for the next SR. He said the Treasury “must look beyond the traditional scorecard period” and the SR will be framed by the PM’s nascent ‘10 Year Plan’. He offered little clarity, but it suggests a break with the conventions of previous exercises. We know the PM and his deputy, Lousie Haigh, want to revise the fiscal rules and the latter explicitly proposed changing the measurement of the debt cycle from one to two parliaments, (i.e. 10 years). To revise the parameters of the upcoming SR at this juncture will be interpreted as being less responsible (and ‘moving the goalposts’) which is the wrong message for investors at the wrong time.
Third, Healey is not pledging to bring down the tax burden nor welfare bills in this parliament – the two are of course linked. Equally, he was not willing to say whether the SR would or would not be a tax raising event. Government pledges to reduce the costs of doing business and boost affordability for households do not sit easily with Healey’s failure to commit to reducing the tax and welfare burden.
It is incredible to claim to be focused on reducing costs and then increase taxes, especially when they are born of a failure to restrain the growth of State spending. This government held a ‘zero-based’ review in 2025 scrutinising every aspect of the government’s £1.3 trillion budget, but did not even quantify the savings identified by it. As the Welfare Secretary, Pat McFadden, told us, Labour MPs as “who can we tax in order to pay benefits to others.”
Finally, the flipside of the fiscal predicament is this government’s opaque plans for growth. Rachel Reeves promised a plan for growth, but it never materialised. Healey likewise.
The Budget contained a record 98 measures, yet the Office for Budget Responsibility did not identify a single measure that met the modest 0.1 per cent threshold for having an impact on growth. The Chancellor, remarkably, was relaxed, saying he isn’t “terribly worried about that” because of the government’s devolution gambit. The records of Wales and Scotland offer scant evidence to support his theory. But it does promise more regulations and newly empowered bureaucrats across the country – which is the ‘Labour way’
Andy Burnham and John Healey’s first Budget was a missed opportunity on many fronts, including growth. This government has done little to make a big pitch for overseas investment. Higher taxes will repel investors and dallying with the EU will confuse matters further.
The Budget was so flat that it has stoked rumours of it being the last of this parliament. If they do intend to hold an election between now and next summer, they will be punished by voters and investors who want to see a government that is prepared to take clear and bold choices on welfare, levels of tax, and defence.