Lord Redwood is a leading commentator on the economy and modern politics, a former industrialist, founder of an investment management company and a distinguished fellow of All Souls College Oxford.
The pandemic was a tragedy for too many families who lost loved ones, and for many whose jobs and businesses were disrupted by what occurred. Ministers had to make rapid decisions with little information to rely on, as experts sought to fight a new disease they did not understand. We all live with the consequences both of the disease and of the dramatic and unusual response governments in the West made to it.
The UK’s policies to tackle COVID destroyed the 2019-2024 UK government, splitting the party and the top Ministerial team. Ministers were popular in the early stages when most people were very worried about the disease. Most liked the way the Central Bank and Treasury printed money and dished out large sums to many people and companies to stay at home and do nothing productive. As the crisis wore on, the Conservative rebellions over the extensive and long lasting lockdowns got bigger in the Commons as we moved from a handful of MPs to over 100 who thought the lockdowns were not saving lives but were doing economic damage.
The communist style approach to directing everyone’s lives and movements palled. The financial excesses were destined to be inflationary when recovery got under way.
The inner cabinet warred between the side that wanted more lockdowns as the main approach to the disease and the side that wanted to relax controls to save more of the economy. One side did not think lockdowns did enough to protect people and did not stop the spread of the virus whilst they did great economic damage. The Chancellor was pitted against the Health Secretary.
As a concerned backbencher myself, there were many things to worry about. There was the constitutional revolution with senior officials fronting national news conferences. I attended many of the online meetings which we requested, to know what was going on. They too were dominated by the senior health officials, with many Ministers acting as amiable chairmen selecting who could ask a question but rarely venturing an answer.
We did not see senior officials representing the economy or normal life side of the argument, only the health policy side.They were bound to recommend ever stronger and longer lockdowns without much thought for everything else that was endangered.
The role of the Minister should be to listen to advice from the health officials, from the COVID experts and from those with wider considerations. Ministers then have to balance the argument and decide the priorities. They should have carried on in the usual way, presenting the final decisions themselves that they reached to people and Parliament. If they wanted a full long lockdown they needed to set out how serious the health threat was and explain how you could contain transmission by lockdown. If they saw the big damage being done to the economy, they needed to find how more economic activity could be allowed without harming the vulnerable who were mainly the elderly.
I worried about the inflationary consequences of the third huge round of money printing and bond buying well into the recovery, when another £150bn was thrown into circulation. Output was unable to match the extra cash. Throughout the crisis the problem was not a shortage of demand requiring more spending, but a shortage of supply through lockdowns. I was concerned by the way waiting lists for any medical condition other than COVID were building up to alarming levels. Was the death rate going up for other conditions?
I was surprised that the NHS did not make sufficient use of all the extra capacity they had access to for non-COVID treatments. The state had bought up most of the capacity of the private hospital system. The private sector could not use the facilities for their own patients who joined the ever longing waiting lists, whilst the operating theatres and consulting rooms in covid free buildings were not often used.
I was annoyed that Ministers who did get through the Nightingale hospitals allowed them to go largely unused. Part of the NHS workforce showed great dedication, courage and hard work to handle all the covid cases whilst others stood down as the main NHS hospitals understandably just concentrated on the pandemic.
The long and expensive inquiry has seemed more interested in the political interplay and the possible personal shortcomings of some Ministers than with understanding the wider problems the pandemic response created.
It should be asking how many lives did lockdown save, given that many people did end up catching the virus. It should be concentrating on the spread of infections in care homes and hospitals and how better airflow control with ultra violet filtering could have helped. Why were vulnerable patients moved around, sometimes into danger? Could more have been done to isolate and protect the elderly who were the main sufferers? Was it really necessary to shut all the schools when young people were at little risk?
As the pandemic response raged on, constituents split into three blocs. One minority wanted longer and tougher lock downs as they were scared of the virus. A second minority bloc thought the whole response was over the top and wanted permission to rescue their businesses or get back to their jobs. The majority accepted the advice of the government but became more critical the longer it went on as more criticisms started to emerge of what had happened.
The Labour and Lib Dem opposition parties did not come up with better ways of handling the crisis and were usually urging more lockdowns and the expenditure of even more money on the never never of artificially cheap debt. They did not warn about the likely coming inflation nor about the way we would lose a lot of self employed and small businesses who lost their income and customers. They did not pursue the big build up of delays for non covid treatments. Many business people decided on early retirement, cutting the capacity of the economy to recover.
As the crisis drew to an end, the opposition whipped up anger about people and companies who had exploited the easy money and the generous grants. They railed against the high costs and sometimes low quality of the bought in protective clothing which had been in world wide shortage. They forgot that all these decisions were made in great haste with the same Opposition demanding more supplies sooner, whatever the cost.
The main economic legacy of the pandemic policies was the big surge in inflation brought on by excessive money, cheap loans and public borrowing. The surge in oil prices was blamed, but UK inflation was three times target before Putin invaded Ukraine, whilst it stayed low in energy imports from China and Japan. Labour played the cost of living card well to undermine the Conservatives, though they had backed the policies that caused it and wanted more. There was also some permanent loss of capacity and output. Attitudes to work and working from home were greatly changed by the long lay off.
By the time of the 2024 election, inflation was back down to target. It is surging again thanks to Labour’s inflation of public sector costs, spending and borrowing. Growth had resumed during the last 6 months of the Conservatives with the UK growing the fastest of the G7.
None of that mattered. The electors had made up their mind. Their experience of lockdown, high inflation and the dislocation of public services caused by the pandemic response was enough to confine that Conservative government to history. The public now watches as the former Opposition who had wanted more of the wrong responses to covid now just make things worse. They did not learn from the experiences that they used to push the Conservatives out of office.