John Oxley is a consultant, writer, and broadcaster. His SubStack is Joxley Writes.
This week has been the Battle of the Benefits Bill, with both Labour and the Conservatives announcing plans to engage with the rising costs of young NEETs.
The government’s Milburn Review has proposed a long, state-intensive approach with multi-billion up-front spending that it hopes will deliver long-term savings. The Conservatives favour quicker welfare cuts to push people back to work, combined with NIC cuts to reduce the cost of hiring.
Tackling the issue of the jobless youth is an essential mission. Being out of work, training, and education for substantial periods has lifelong implications. It makes people more likely to fall into bad habits that restrict their enjoyment of life. A lot of that cost also falls on the state, which has to deal with the consequences of people who end up poorer, sicker, and more troubled than those who manage to maintain work.
Yet when we discuss the rising costs of benefits, there is a real elephant in the room. Like most pachyderms, it is grey, wrinkled, long-lived, and expensive to care for. I’m talking, admittedly slightly cruelly, about the other element of our welfare bill: pensioners.
For all our concern about the rising costs of out-of-work benefits, state pensions are by far the largest line item in the welfare budget. Payments now account for nearly half of the country’s welfare spending and continue to grow year on year. This is partly a product of demography, with the baby boom of the fifties and sixties now reaching retirement, and older cohorts living longer, but also of policy – most of all, the triple lock.
Since its inception, the Triple Lock has pushed pensions up in real terms, often when the rest of the economy stayed still. The framing of it worked to create a “heads the old win, tails the young lose” phenomenon. In years when inflation raced ahead of wages, pensioners got the former. When inflation fell, and wages recovered, they got the latter. The resulting real-terms increases have been welcome and have alleviated much pensioner poverty. But they have come at the expense of higher taxes and a squeeze on benefits for working-age people.
Politically, this is hard to resolve and outside of the wonky world of think tanks there is actually little pressure to undo the triple lock. It is, of course, popular with pensioners, who vote in large numbers and benefit from it, but also with younger voters. Few want to strip their grandparents or parents of money, and many understand that they will be the long-term beneficiaries of ever-increasing state pensions. Even taking supplemental benefits away from old people is a political challenge, as seen by the row over Winter Fuel when Keir Starmer tried to rescind it.
Structural problems also mean the old age benefit bill is likely to rise, not fall. Alongside an ageing population, we are looking at coming cohorts that are likely to be worse off than current pensioners in old age. Our state provision is lower than many comparable countries, but assumes that people will have built up private, workplace pensions. While some have, especially those who worked in the public sector, more people in their 50s and 60s will reach retirement without substantial savings.
This lack of private provision is worsened by issues with housing costs. Of current pensioners, nearly 80% own their homes, and almost all own outright or with minimal mortgages. This reduces their housing costs in retirement to almost zero and gives them an asset that can be cashed in. Most of the remainder live in social housing, which at least offers security and predictability. This is less true for those reaching retirement age in the coming decades, and many will struggle to afford the costs and insecurity of the private rental market.
With these challenges come fresh problems of inequality. Stereotypes of pensioner poverty from decades ago have given way to images of cruise-taking, home-owning, unearned-income-drawing older people. Both were oversimplifications, but in coming years the difference is likely to seem starker. Those who did well through their working life and invested prudently will be comfortable in old age. Those who were unable to will really struggle, with rising costs, insecure housing and few ways to raise their income.
Such a disparity is a challenge for policymakers. Broadly speaking, the pension is a universal benefit. Raising it through the triple lock benefits everyone, from retired company executives to former cleaners. The richest will pay some of it back as income tax, but broad raises are expensive for the government and poorly directed. For working-age people, we resist this sort of universalism, yet for the old it has become standard – backed by the widely held, but false, presumption that pensions are already paid for by National Insurance contributions.
The triple lock has done its job of raising old age pensions. Now it contributes to our booming welfare bill.
According to the OBR, the policy will have added about £15.5 billion to state pension spending each year by 2029-2030 – up from the £5.2 billion a year that was originally costed. Maintaining it would shift further burdens onto working-age people. Reducing it to a simple tie to earnings increases would shift the balance back towards working people. The impact on the poorest pensioners could be softened by more support through Pension Credit.
The Conservative Party is comfortable talking about cuts to working age benefits. We baulked at removing Winter Fuel Payments – a relatively small payment, given to people who often don’t need it. There were political advantages to that approach, but it also smacked of fiscal NIMBYism, a politics that wants to cut until it starts impacting our own voters. Our current plans look to significantly reduce working-age benefits but leave pensioner payments untouched. A party that wants credit for being serious about welfare can’t leave its biggest line item off the table.
The debate on the young NEETs is an important one.
Any government serious about allowing people to flourish needs to engage with helping them into work. Equally, any party serious about saving the state money needs to reduce welfare payments, whilst maintaining a floor of basic fairness. The young, however, are not the main draw on our welfare system – the old are. Unless we are content to see that bill rise and rise, we need to face politically difficult choices at the other end of our demography.
The Conservative Party has to decide if it is willing to take that risk, too.